2350: Deer Turrets - Revision history

172.71.30.192: Minor edit

2024-02-15T15:14:21Z

Minor edit

Tromag at 22:33, 2 January 2024

2024-01-02T22:33:30Z

172.70.55.60: Phrased it poorly but pretty sure there was an implied joke with "Hindenburg was filled with hydrogen gas so it being vulnerable to catching fire would make it iceberg proof"

2023-10-02T23:31:00Z

Phrased it poorly but pretty sure there was an implied joke with "Hindenburg was filled with hydrogen gas so it being vulnerable to catching fire would make it iceberg proof"

Jacky720: rv

2022-05-04T21:00:08Z

Show changes

Ex Kay Cee Dee at 20:58, 4 May 2022

2022-05-04T20:58:48Z

Show changes

Davidy22: Reverted edits by X. K. C. D. (talk) to last revision by Btx40

2022-05-04T01:58:13Z

Reverted edits by X. K. C. D. (talk) to last revision by Btx40

Show changes

X. K. C. D. at 01:00, 4 May 2022

2022-05-04T01:00:22Z

Show changes

Btx40: /* Explanation */ Change caliber link to be more general

2020-10-13T16:03:28Z

‎Explanation: Change caliber link to be more general

162.158.148.172: /* Explanation */

2020-09-23T15:08:15Z

‎Explanation

Opalmagpie: Removed title text from transcript

2020-09-22T23:47:57Z

Removed title text from transcript

@@ Line 21: / Line 21: @@
 In the title text, Black Hat claims that his great grandfather designed the RMS ''{{w|Titanic}}'', the then-largest ocean-liner in the world which {{w|Sinking of the Titanic|sank after striking an iceberg}} in 1912, and the ''{{w|LZ 129 Hindenburg}}'', the then-largest airship in the world which {{w|Hindenburg disaster|caught fire and crashed}} in 1937. He claims that his ancestor did not retire from the design business after the loss of the ''Titanic'', but instead learned from it and made the ''Hindenburg'' "iceberg-proof". This is an obvious and humorous lie for several reasons. First, the lead designers of the ''Olympic''-class ''Titanic'' and the ''Hindenburg''-class airship were two different people, {{w|William Pirrie, 1st Viscount Pirrie|Lord Pirrie}} and Dr. {{w|Ludwig Dürr}} respectively, and Black Hat is probably not one of Dürr's great-grandsons (Lord Pirrie had no children). Secondly, while no airship has been recorded to be destroyed by striking an iceberg, it's not because of any "iceberg-proofing" efforts by Black Hat's great-grandfather, or anyone else -- it's just due to the basic fact that airships fly in the air, where there are no icebergs.{{Citation needed}} Were an airship to strike an iceberg, it would almost certainly be destroyed; in fact, the even deadlier accident on the airship {{w|USS Akron|USS ''Akron''}} resulted from the airship simply striking the (unfrozen) ocean.
-There is also the implication that the "iceberg proofing" is where the project went awry - a hot enough fire will melt an iceberg, so it may be implied that the "iceberg proofing" was intentionally filling the airship with flammable hydrogen gas so it would explode and melt the iceberg on impact. It is unclear how this would be remotely helpful in case of iceberg collision, but give the fate of the Hindenburg, it is very ironic.
+There is also the implication that the "iceberg proofing" is where the project went awry - a hot enough fire will melt an iceberg, so it may be implied that the "iceberg proofing" was intentionally filling the airship with flammable hydrogen gas so it would explode and melt the iceberg on impact. It is unclear how this would be remotely helpful in case of iceberg collision, but it would be very ironic given the fate of the Hindenburg.
 The possibility of mounting devices on wild deer was previously referenced in the title text of [[1924: Solar Panels]].

@@ Line 8: / Line 8: @@
 ==Explanation==
-[[Black Hat]] has built laser turrets that automatically shoot at nearby wireless devices. This could potentially be useful in a military context, but for [[72|reasons unforeseeable]], he's gone and strapped them to local deer. Deer are well-defined by their tendency to move around (which [[Cueball]] attempted to exploit for ergonomic reasons in [[1329: Standing]]), typically in areas close to civilization, so attaching wireless-seeking laser robots to them effectively makes them organic killbots. As the last panel reveals, this can be circumvented by disabling wireless access on your devices (airplane mode), though Black Hat doesn't seem particularly concerned with letting people know this, and seems to brush these inventions off as simple mistakes.  At least one member of the press isn't convinced, sarcastically asking "''is it really''?!"  It's not clear if the reporter is asking if it's really "another mistake" (i.e. expressing that this was Black Hat's plan all along), or if it's really "okay", but Black Hat chooses to interpret the question as meaning the latter, and declares that he thinks everything's fine -- after all, he's not the one getting shot by deer-mounted lasers.
+In this comic [[Black Hat]] is giving what appears to be a press conference, in which he's offering a non-apology for his recent actions. This is not uncommon in politics and the military, in which the speaker offers bland admissions, such as "mistakes were made", while minimizing the importance of whatever happened.
 The title, "Deer Turrets," may be a pun on "deterrents," as laser turrets would certainly deter people with wireless devices from approaching deer.

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:31, 2 October 2023
Line 17:		Line 17:

	In the title text, Black Hat claims that his great grandfather designed the RMS ''{{w\|Titanic}}'', the then-largest ocean-liner in the world which {{w\|Sinking of the Titanic\|sank after striking an iceberg}} in 1912, and the ''{{w\|LZ 129 Hindenburg}}'', the then-largest airship in the world which {{w\|Hindenburg disaster\|caught fire and crashed}} in 1937. He claims that his ancestor did not retire from the design business after the loss of the ''Titanic'', but instead learned from it and made the ''Hindenburg'' "iceberg-proof". This is an obvious and humorous lie for several reasons. First, the lead designers of the ''Olympic''-class ''Titanic'' and the ''Hindenburg''-class airship were two different people, {{w\|William Pirrie, 1st Viscount Pirrie\|Lord Pirrie}} and Dr. {{w\|Ludwig Dürr}} respectively, and Black Hat is probably not one of Dürr's great-grandsons (Lord Pirrie had no children). Secondly, while no airship has been recorded to be destroyed by striking an iceberg, it's not because of any "iceberg-proofing" efforts by Black Hat's great-grandfather, or anyone else -- it's just due to the basic fact that airships fly in the air, where there are no icebergs.{{Citation needed}} Were an airship to strike an iceberg, it would almost certainly be destroyed; in fact, the even deadlier accident on the airship {{w\|USS Akron\|USS ''Akron''}} resulted from the airship simply striking the (unfrozen) ocean.		In the title text, Black Hat claims that his great grandfather designed the RMS ''{{w\|Titanic}}'', the then-largest ocean-liner in the world which {{w\|Sinking of the Titanic\|sank after striking an iceberg}} in 1912, and the ''{{w\|LZ 129 Hindenburg}}'', the then-largest airship in the world which {{w\|Hindenburg disaster\|caught fire and crashed}} in 1937. He claims that his ancestor did not retire from the design business after the loss of the ''Titanic'', but instead learned from it and made the ''Hindenburg'' "iceberg-proof". This is an obvious and humorous lie for several reasons. First, the lead designers of the ''Olympic''-class ''Titanic'' and the ''Hindenburg''-class airship were two different people, {{w\|William Pirrie, 1st Viscount Pirrie\|Lord Pirrie}} and Dr. {{w\|Ludwig Dürr}} respectively, and Black Hat is probably not one of Dürr's great-grandsons (Lord Pirrie had no children). Secondly, while no airship has been recorded to be destroyed by striking an iceberg, it's not because of any "iceberg-proofing" efforts by Black Hat's great-grandfather, or anyone else -- it's just due to the basic fact that airships fly in the air, where there are no icebergs.{{Citation needed}} Were an airship to strike an iceberg, it would almost certainly be destroyed; in fact, the even deadlier accident on the airship {{w\|USS Akron\|USS ''Akron''}} resulted from the airship simply striking the (unfrozen) ocean.
		+	There is also the implication that the "iceberg proofing" is where the project went awry - a hot enough fire will melt an iceberg, so it may be implied that the "iceberg proofing" was intentionally filling the airship with flammable hydrogen gas so it would explode and melt the iceberg on impact. It is unclear how this would be remotely helpful in case of iceberg collision, but give the fate of the Hindenburg, it is very ironic.

	The possibility of mounting devices on wild deer was previously referenced in the title text of [[1924: Solar Panels]].		The possibility of mounting devices on wild deer was previously referenced in the title text of [[1924: Solar Panels]].

@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 The title, "Deer Turrets," may be a pun on "deterrents," as laser turrets would certainly deter people with wireless devices from approaching deer.
-In the second panel Black Hat uses the common idiom "hindsight is {{w|Visual acuity#Expression|20/20}}". This may be a pun, as "hind" is a term for an adult female (doe) deer - as {{w|Red_deer#Behaviour|a counterpoint}} to the adult male (buck) deer being known as a "stag" - and a "sight" is a {{w|Sight_(device)|visual aligning device}}, often for weaponry. Whether or not the potential pun has any further {{w|.30-30_Winchester|caliber}} to its references, this ''might'' be the ultimate aim of this wording.
+In the second panel Black Hat uses the common idiom "hindsight is {{w|Visual acuity#Expression|20/20}}". This may be a pun, as "hind" is a term for an adult female (doe) deer - as {{w|Red_deer#Behaviour|a counterpoint}} to the adult male (buck) deer being known as a "stag" - and a "sight" is a {{w|Sight_(device)|visual aligning device}}, often for weaponry. Whether or not the potential pun has any further {{w|caliber}} to its references, this ''might'' be the ultimate aim of this wording.
 The auto-targeting laser turrets may be a reference to attempts by researchers at the University of Washington to create a laser-based battery charging device [https://www.wired.com/story/wireless-charging-with-lasers/]. The device in question is mounted on a turret that locates and aims the beam at a photovoltaic cell attached to the battery. The same technology could theoretically be used with a higher-powered laser, but for the application described in the comic, the targeting mechanism would need to be altered to sense any electronic rather than the accompanying photovoltaic cell.

← Older revision		Revision as of 15:08, 23 September 2020
Line 8:		Line 8:

	==Explanation==		==Explanation==
−	~~{{incomplete\|Created by a NEIGHBORHOOD DEER (PEW PEW). Explain what a laser turret is. Please mention here why this explanation isn't complete. Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}}~~
	[[Black Hat]] has built laser turrets that automatically shoot at nearby wireless devices. This could potentially be useful in a military context, but for [[72\|reasons unforeseeable]], he's gone and strapped them to local deer. Deer are well-defined by their tendency to move around (which [[Cueball]] attempted to exploit for ergonomic reasons in [[1329: Standing]]), typically in areas close to civilization, so attaching wireless-seeking laser robots to them effectively makes them organic killbots. As the last panel reveals, this can be circumvented by disabling wireless access on your devices (airplane mode), though Black Hat doesn't seem particularly concerned with letting people know this, and seems to brush these inventions off as simple mistakes. At least one member of the press isn't convinced, sarcastically asking "''is it really''?!" It's not clear if the reporter is asking if it's really "another mistake" (i.e. expressing that this was Black Hat's plan all along), or if it's really "okay", but Black Hat chooses to interpret the question as meaning the latter, and declares that he thinks everything's fine -- after all, he's not the one getting shot by deer-mounted lasers.		[[Black Hat]] has built laser turrets that automatically shoot at nearby wireless devices. This could potentially be useful in a military context, but for [[72\|reasons unforeseeable]], he's gone and strapped them to local deer. Deer are well-defined by their tendency to move around (which [[Cueball]] attempted to exploit for ergonomic reasons in [[1329: Standing]]), typically in areas close to civilization, so attaching wireless-seeking laser robots to them effectively makes them organic killbots. As the last panel reveals, this can be circumvented by disabling wireless access on your devices (airplane mode), though Black Hat doesn't seem particularly concerned with letting people know this, and seems to brush these inventions off as simple mistakes. At least one member of the press isn't convinced, sarcastically asking "''is it really''?!" It's not clear if the reporter is asking if it's really "another mistake" (i.e. expressing that this was Black Hat's plan all along), or if it's really "okay", but Black Hat chooses to interpret the question as meaning the latter, and declares that he thinks everything's fine -- after all, he's not the one getting shot by deer-mounted lasers.

@@ Line 44: / Line 44: @@
 :Black Hat: I think it's fine.
 :Deer: ''Pew! Pew!''
-<br>
 {{comic discussion}}
 [[Category: Comics featuring Black Hat]]
 [[Category: Animals]]