2736: Only Serifs - Revision history

Natg19: add cat

2025-07-10T16:54:57Z

add cat

172.70.163.11: Undo revision 359450 by 172.71.219.103 (talk) Red category

2024-12-14T04:27:01Z

Undo revision 359450 by 172.71.219.103 (talk) Red category

172.71.219.103 at 02:57, 14 December 2024

2024-12-14T02:57:08Z

CalibansCreations: /* Explanation */

2024-10-15T10:45:49Z

‎Explanation

Jkshapiro: General cleanup

2023-12-13T03:16:33Z

General cleanup

Kynde: /* Explanation */

2023-02-13T13:49:21Z

‎Explanation

Kynde: /* Explanation */ Adding image of title text suggested font as posten in comment by NiceGuy. Also adding links t my hobby and banned from conference catgory

2023-02-13T13:48:56Z

‎Explanation: Adding image of title text suggested font as posten in comment by NiceGuy. Also adding links t my hobby and banned from conference catgory

Kynde: /* Transcript */

2023-02-13T13:35:17Z

‎Transcript

Kynde: /* Transcript */More details and less explanation

2023-02-13T13:34:34Z

‎Transcript: More details and less explanation

141.101.98.108: /* Transcript / Removed* title-text from Transcript (as per established site practice).

2023-02-13T00:32:47Z

‎Transcript: *Removed* title-text from Transcript (as per established site practice).

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:54, 10 July 2025
Line 28:		Line 28:

	[[Category:Language]]		[[Category:Language]]
		+	[[Category:Graphic designers]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 04:27, 14 December 2024
Line 28:		Line 28:

	[[Category:Language]]		[[Category:Language]]
−	~~[[Category:Typography]]~~

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:57, 14 December 2024
Line 28:		Line 28:

	[[Category:Language]]		[[Category:Language]]
		+	[[Category:Typography]]

@@ Line 16: / Line 16: @@
 As for the title text, {{w|Times New Roman}} is a widely available and recognized typeface with serifs, being one of the most commonly used fonts of its type. {{w|Comic Sans}} is a ''mostly'' sans-serif typeface (hence the “Sans” in the name) inspired by comic book lettering. Many graphic designers {{w|Comic_Sans#Opposition|dislike Comic Sans}} due to a history of amateurs using it in contexts where its informal style is inappropriate. Defenders claim that it is easier for dyslexics to read (although this is disputed), and that it works well in less formal, typically children's contexts. Randall is suggesting here that if you want to severely anger a bunch of graphic designers (i.e. enough to beat you up), then you should try removing the characteristic and aesthetic serifs on Times New Roman and add them instead to the hated Comic Sans – which would probably make it look even worse to a graphic designer.
-One of the users of Explain xkcd took the chance anyway of getting that beating and here is what it looks like normally and what it might look like after moving the serifs: <br>
+[[:User:NiceGuy1|One of the users of explain xkcd]] took the chance anyway of getting that beating and here is what it looks like normally and what it might look like after moving the serifs: <br>
 [[File:2736MovedSerifsV2.jpg]]

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 ==Explanation==
-This is a play upon the main difference between {{w|serif}} and {{w|sans-serif}} fonts. Serifs are ticks, or end-bars, at the ends of lines that make up letters, commonly used in most books and newspapers and also seen in {{w|Calligraphy|calligraphic}} lettering (written with a flat-nibbed pen) and {{w|Signwriter|signwriting}} (often painted and detailed with fine brushes). Rather than mere lines, there are (for example) "feet" put at the bottom of a letter such as <span style="font-family: Serif;">A</span>, and possibly also at angles such as its peak. (In the comic, the first three elements appear to be of such an "A", with the text as a whole appearing to be "<span style="font-family: Serif;">Aa Bb Cc Dd</span>"). Fonts that use this visual decoration are called "Serif" fonts, while others do not and are thus "Sans Serif" fonts ("sans" being French for "without"). [[Randall]] is suggesting a font using ''only'' these accent pieces and skipping the "body" of the letters entirely. Of course, this renders the text basically unreadable, or at least you need good imagination and code breaking skills.
+This is a play upon the main difference between {{w|serif}} and {{w|sans-serif}} fonts. Serifs are ticks, or end-bars, at the ends of lines that make up letters. Rather than mere lines, there are (for example) "feet" put at the bottom of a letter such as <span style="font-family: Serif;">A</span>, and possibly also at angles such as its peak. Fonts that use this visual decoration are called "Serif" fonts, while others do not and are thus "Sans Serif" fonts ("sans" being French for "without"). [[Randall]] is suggesting a font using ''only'' these accent pieces and skipping the "body" of the letters entirely. Of course, this renders the text basically unreadable.
-As for the title text, {{w|Times New Roman}} is a widely available and recognized typeface with serifs, being one of the most commonly used fonts of its type. {{w|Comic Sans}} is a ''mostly'' sans-serif typeface (hence the “Sans” in the name) designed to look like (non-{{w|cursive}}, or {{w|Block letters|block}}-style) handwriting, more akin to a basic and unadorned lettering written freehand by thick-nibbed pen, paintbrush, spraycan or chalk/marker upon a blackboard/whiteboard. Many graphic designers {{w|Comic_Sans#Opposition|dislike Comic Sans}} due to a history of amateurs using it in contexts where its informal style is inappropriate, simply in order to vary the font away from the standards of Times or Arial styles (two major serifed and non-serifed families of font, respectively). Defenders claim that it is easier for dyslexics to read, and that it works well in less formal, typically children's contexts. Randall is suggesting here that if you want to severely anger a bunch of graphic designers (i.e. enough to beat you up), then you should try removing the characteristic and aesthetic serifs on Times New Roman and add them instead to the hated Comic Sans – which would probably make it look even worse to a graphic designer.
+In the comic, the text as a whole appears to be "<span style="font-family: Serif;">Aa Bb Cc Dd</span>", perhaps written in variant #3 or variant #540 of {{w|Caslon}}.
 One of the users of Explain xkcd took the chance anyway of getting that beating and here is what it looks like normally and what it might look like after moving the serifs: <br>
 [[File:2736MovedSerifsV2.jpg]]
 Randall has had numerous careers and [[:Category:My Hobby|hobbies]] where he has delighted in exploring novel methods of resolving disputes, all of which has satisfied nobody and led to him being banned from numerous [[:Category:Banned from conferences|events]].
 ==Transcript==

@@ Line 20: / Line 20: @@
 ==Transcript==
-:[A very thin comic panel with three light gray horizontal lines drawn, as on ruled paper used for handwriting.  Superimposed on these ruling lines are 15 black markings, either in the form of lines, horizontal or vertical, and in other cases merely dots, and some markings are in between, like a dot with a small line. These marks line up with either the top, middle or bottom ruling lines, with only two dots on near the middle line. There seem to be no order in how these markings are placed. There is a caption beneath the panel:]
+:[A very thin comic panel with three light gray horizontal lines drawn as on ruled paper used for handwriting.  Superimposed on these ruling lines are 15 black markings, either in the form of lines, horizontal or vertical, and in other cases merely dots, and some markings are in between, like a dot with a small line. These marks line up with either the top, middle or bottom ruling lines, with only two dots near the middle line. There seem to be no order in how these markings are placed. There is a caption beneath the panel:]
 :Instead of serif or sans-serif, my new font is '''''only''''' serifs.

@@ Line 25: / Line 25: @@
 :my new font is '''''only''''' serifs.
 {{comic discussion}}
 [[Category: Language]]