Editing 1785: Wifi
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
==Explanation== | ==Explanation== | ||
− | This comic shows the supposed probability that a guest will be able to connect to the owner's {{w|Wi-Fi}} in graph form. | + | This comic shows the supposed probability that a guest will be able to connect to the owner's {{w|Wi-Fi}} in graph form. Connecting to a new Wi-Fi network typically requires selecting the correct network name on a settings screen, then entering a password. |
− | The graph starts with tech-illiterate people who don't even know how to control their Wi-Fi connection ("can't find wifi settings"). This group has slightly lower than normal probability of connecting successfully, since they would not know what to do if left alone. However, they still have a reasonable chance to connect as long as someone is available to help them. Once the initial setup is done, they can continue using the connection without any technical knowledge or intervention. | + | The graph starts with tech-illiterate people who don't even know how to control their Wi-Fi connection ("can't find wifi settings"). This group has slightly lower than normal probability of connecting successfully, since they would not know what to do if left alone. However, they still have a reasonable chance to connect as long as someone is available to help them. Once the initial setup is done, they can continue using the connection without any technical knowledge or intervention. |
− | The average case in the middle of the graph represents typical users who simply wish to connect and gain Internet access ("works fine"). This group of users have enough knowledge to be able to connect and are then satisfied with the connection just working. | + | The average case in the middle of the graph represents typical users who simply wish to connect and gain Internet access ("works fine"). This group of users have enough knowledge to be able to connect and are then satisfied with the connection just working. Since networking devices use a standard protocol to communicate, users typically will not experience any issues. |
− | Finally, the large drop in the graph on the right-hand side is explained by "something involving the word 'firmware'". {{w|Firmware}} is programming which operates a device at the lowest level, typically stored in a {{w|ROM}} or an EEPROM/flash. | + | Finally, the large drop in the graph on the right-hand side is explained by "something involving the word 'firmware'". {{w|Firmware}} is programming which operates a device at the lowest level, typically stored in a {{w|ROM}} or an EEPROM/flash. The comic may be referring to either the firmware of the host's {{w|wireless router}}, that of the guest's device (smartphone, tablet, or laptop computer), or both. Modifying the firmware can have certain benefits, for example to gain features that aren't included in the base product. Also, especially for newly adopted wireless standards (such as, most recently, {{w|IEEE 802.11ac}}), incompatible interpretations of the standard may prevent devices from different manufacturers from communicating reliably or at full speed. |
+ | However, updating or replacing firmware requires a great deal of technical knowledge, and can be quite risky for people without experience. Not all custom firmware will interoperate correctly with all devices. Technical issues with custom firmware can also be harder to fix due to lack of support from the device manufacturer. In the worst case, installing the wrong firmware, or any errors or glitches in the process, can even leave devices "{{w|brick (electronics)|bricked}}" (inoperable and unrecoverable). It's likely that the sharp dropoff in the graph is caused by inexperienced users who know "just enough" to want to modify their firmware, but don't know how to deal with the multitude of issues that can arise. Particularly for users whose connection was already working fine but nevertheless want to experiment with new firmware, their changes often end up worsening their chances of connecting. | ||
− | The title text indicates that the curve recovers once users are more experienced, and ''can'' consistently install firmware correctly to get a working connection. In such case, the users are able to enjoy better connections through their firmware changes while avoiding their pitfalls. These experienced users are often able to diagnose and fix connection issues through the appropriate use of firmware, making their chances of connecting even better than the average user. | + | The title text indicates that the curve recovers once users are more experienced, and ''can'' consistently install firmware correctly to get a working connection. In such case, the users are able to enjoy better connections through their firmware changes while avoiding their pitfalls. These experienced users are often able to diagnose and fix connection issues through the appropriate use of firmware, making their chances of connecting even better than the average user. |
− | + | These computer issues have previously appeared in several xkcd comics, notably [[456: Cautionary]], where WiFi problems specifically are mentioned in the title text. | |
− | + | The apparent paradox of people knowing more about a subject also having more problems with it is also explored in [[1760: TV Problems]]; in the title text, the ones who are more likely to die from a skydiving accident are the ones who know the more about skydiving safety, but that is of course not because they cannot make it work, but rather because they make many more dives than regular people, thus increasing the overall risk in spite of their competence. | |
− | |||
− | The apparent paradox of people knowing more about a subject also having more problems with it is also explored in [[1760: TV Problems]]. | ||
==Transcript== | ==Transcript== | ||
− | :[A line graph with a curve that starts just | + | :[A line graph with a curve that starts just left of the Y-axis above the middle of the axis. Then it increases slightly and stays almost stable on a long flat plateau before it falls off fast towards the right. Each axis ends in an arrow and has a label to the left of the Y-axis and below the x-axis. Over the curve there are three labels, pointing with one arrow to the two rising and falling parts, and three arrows to the center label above the plateau.] |
:Y-axis: Probability houseguest will be able to connect to WiFi | :Y-axis: Probability houseguest will be able to connect to WiFi | ||
:X-axis: Houseguest tech-savviness | :X-axis: Houseguest tech-savviness |