Editing 1727: Number of Computers

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
This comic shows a {{w|semi-log plot}} with two red lines. The first line shows the increasing rate that {{w|computers}} have been created since the first came around in the 1940s. The graph shows this to occur around 1946. ({{w|Computer#First_computing_device|The precise date can be discussed}} but it was {{w|Computer#Digital_computers|around that time}} that the concept began to be applied to real working machines.) After the first computer, the number of computers created is shown to increase in a roughly straight line, indicating {{w|exponential growth}}. At the time of this comic's release in 2016, the curve has passed 10 billion computers, and its projection into the 2020s predicts that the number of computers will keep rising exponentially for at least 10 years to come.
+
{{incomplete|Rough draft, needs better phrasing and transcript}}
 +
This comic shows a {{w|semi-log plot}} with two red lines. The first line shows the increasing rate that {{w|computers}} have been created since the first came around in the 1940s. The graph shows this to occur around 1946. (The {{w|Computer#First_computing_device|precise date can be discussed}}, because when is a machine actually a computer? But it was {{w|Computer#Digital_computers|around that time}} that the concept began to be used on real working machines). After the first computer the number of computers created is shown to increase in a straight line, thus indicating {{w|exponential growth}}. At the time of the comics release (in 2016) the curve has passed above the 10 billion computers mark, and its projection into the 2020s predicts the numbers of computers to keep rising exponentially for at least 10 years to come.
  
The other plot on this graph represents all the computers destroyed by throwing them into {{w|Jupiter}}. So far this is only true for the computers on two [[:Category:Space probes|space probes]]: those on the {{w|Galileo (spacecraft)|Galileo orbiter}} and its {{w|Galileo Probe|probe}}. The latter's mission was to fly into Jupiter so it went first in 1995; the orbiter went only after it had completed its mission in 2003. That constitutes the first two steps on the graph.  
+
The other graph represents all the computers destroyed by throwing them into {{w|Jupiter}}. So far this has only worked for the computers on two [[:Category:Space probes|space probes]], those on the {{w|Galileo (spacecraft)|Galileo orbiter}} and its {{w|Galileo Probe|probe}}, the latter's mission was to fly into Jupiter so it went first in 1995, the orbiter went only after it had completed its mission in 2003. That constitutes the first two steps on the graph.  
  
Recently the {{w|Juno (spacecraft)|Juno space probe}} entered into orbit (as only the second after Galileo), and that was celebrated with [[1703: Juno]] on xkcd. Juno's main mission has hardly begun yet; as at the time of this comic's release, it is not even in its final orbit. But once its mission is completed, it will also crash into Jupiter thus destroying a third computer. This is shown as the third step, but this section is shown with a dotted line, as the destruction may still fail if {{w|NASA}} loses contact with the probe before giving it the order to {{w|deorbit}} into Jupiter. This is now scheduled to occur in 2025. All three steps on the graph fits with these years. (Note the number of computers created is not drawn with a dotted line into the future, probably because [[Randall]] believes this continued increase in numbers of computers to be quite certain over the next 10-20 years, whereas the outcome of a space probe mission is never certain, even when the probe is already in orbit and only 1½ years before scheduled deorbit!)
+
Recently the {{w|Juno (spacecraft)|Juno space probe}} entered into orbit (as only the second after Galileo) and that was celebrated with [[1703: Juno]] on xkcd. Juno's main mission has hardly begun yet, as, at the time of this comics release, it is not even in its final orbit. But once its mission is completed it will also crash into Jupiter thus destroying a third computer. This is shown as the third step, but this section is shown with a dotted line, as the destruction may still fail, if {{w|NASA}} loose contact with the probe before giving it the order to {{w|deorbit}} into Jupiter. This is scheduled to occur in 2018. All three steps on the graph fits with these years. (Note the number of computer created is not drawn with a dotted line into the future, probably because [[Randall]] believes this continued increase in numbers of computers to be quite certain over the next 10-20 years, whereas the outcome of a space probe mission is never certain, even when the probe is already in orbit and only 1½ year before scheduled deorbit!)
  
Space probes sent to Jupiter are typically scheduled to deorbit and fall into Jupiter's atmosphere. There can be several reasons for this, but one very important reason is to avoid {{w|Interplanetary contamination|contaminating}} {{w|Moons of Jupiter|Jupiter's moons}} with Earth {{w|pathogens}}, especially the four {{w|Galilean moons}} including {{w|Europa (moon)|Europa}} which {{w|Juno_(spacecraft)#Deorbit_and_disintegration|may harbor life}}. Also the huge [[681|gravity well]] of Jupiter that would have to be overcome for such a probe to leave the planet again makes it impossible to have an orbiting probe return to Earth with samples.
+
Space probes sent to Jupiter are typically scheduled to deorbit and fall into Jupiter's atmosphere. There can be several reasons for this, but one very important it to avoid {{w|Interplanetary contamination|contaminating}} {{w|Moons of Jupiter|Jupiter's moons}} with Earth {{w|pathogens}}, especially the four {{w|Galilean moons}} including {{w|Europa (moon)|Europa}} which {{w|Juno_(spacecraft)#Deorbit_and_disintegration|may harbor life}}. Also the huge [[681|gravity well]] of Jupiter that would have to be overcome for such a probe to leave the planet again, makes it impossible to have an orbiting probe return to Earth with samples.
  
The caption below the comic humorously implies that NASA's reasons for causing the probes to deorbit into Jupiter is merely an attempt to destroy all the computers of the world. The caption notes that they are failing horribly, given that they have destroyed only three computers out of more than 10 billion. However, due to the semi-log scale, those three computers appear to have more significance than they actually have. The caption states that NASA really needs to pick up the pace (having only destroyed two since the 1940s, when computers were created), if they wish to actually finish the job of destroying all computers by hurling them into Jupiter. In addition, seeing as there have been many computers destroyed by other means, NASA will never actually catch up, no matter how hard they try, making this statistic even more irrelevant.
+
The caption below the comic humorously implies that NASA's reasons for causing the probes to deorbit into Jupiter is merely as a mean for destroying all the computers of the world. The caption notes that they are failing horribly, given they have destroyed three computers out of more than 10 billions. However, due to the semi-log scale, those three computers seem as much more than they actually represents. The caption states that NASA really needs to pick up the pace (having only destroyed two since 1945 when computers were created), if they wish to actually finish the job of destroying all computers by hurling them in to Jupiter.
  
Destroying unwanted objects by hurling them into Jupiter pokes fun at the common science fiction trope of destroying objects by hurling them into the Sun [http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HurlItIntoTheSun].  Hurling objects into the Sun is in fact extremely difficult because of the need to cancel out the orbital velocity of the earth.  Randall may be referencing calculations ([https://qntm.org/destroy#sec3], see item 11) that show that hurling items into Jupiter requires 38% less energy than hurling them into the Sun.
+
The title text continues the caption, by telling that in NASA's annual reports they try to make their numbers look better by counting the redundant computer system on Galileo and its probe, thus doubling the numbers of destroyed computers to four. This of course makes no difference out of 10 billions, which is also noted. This indicate that this is a top priority for NASA. That NASA might try to make themselves look better in a report, by doubling a number, could be realistic, to get better funding...
 
 
The title text continues the caption by mentioning that in NASA's annual reports they try to make their numbers look better by counting the redundant computer systems on Galileo and its probe, thus doubling the numbers of destroyed computers to four. This of course makes no big difference given the exponential growth of computer production, which is also noted. This indicates that this is a top priority for NASA. That NASA might try to make themselves look better in a report by doubling a number could be realistic, presumably for political reasons or to get better funding.
 
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
:[A graph with two red lines. The X-axis is a time-line with eight ticks with every second tick labeled below the axis, ranging from around 1940 to 2030. The Y-axis is a logarithmic count ranging from 1 to 1 billion. There are 12 ticks with the first and then every third tick after that larger than the two ticks in between. All the large ticks are labeled, but only the first two of the small ticks are similarly labeled. Labels are written to the left of the axis. All labels on both axes are written in gray. The first red line is a straight line (thus exponentially growing), starting close to the bottom left corner eventually reaching the upper right edge of the graph. The other red line begins around 1990 and has three straight steps. Each step is labeled with gray text, the last part of the line (after the present 2016), is dotted. Both of the red lines have an arrow pointing to them with a label above the arrow.]
+
:[A graph with two red lines. The X-axis is a time-line with eight ticks with every second tick labeled below the axis, ranging from around 1940 to 2030. The Y-axis is a logarithmic count ranging from one to 100 billion. There are 12 ticks with the first and then every third tick after that larger than the two ticks in between. All the large ticks are labeled, but only the first two of the small ticks are similarly labeled. Labels are written to the left of the axis. All labels on both axes are written in gray. The first red line is a straight line (thus exponentially growing), starting close to the bottom left corner eventually reaching the upper right edge of the graph. The other red line begins around 1990 and has three straight steps. Each step is labeled with gray text, the last part of the line (after the present 2016), is dotted. Both of the red lines have an arrow pointing to them with a label above the arrow.]
 
:Left red line: Number of computers created
 
:Left red line: Number of computers created
 
:Right red line: Number of computers destroyed by hurling them into Jupiter
 
:Right red line: Number of computers destroyed by hurling them into Jupiter
:Labels on right red line:
+
:Labels on right red line:<font color="gray">
::<font color="gray">Galileo probe</font>
+
::Galileo probe
::<font color="gray">Galileo orbiter</font>
+
::Galileo orbiter
::<font color="gray">Juno (scheduled)</font>
+
::Juno (scheduled)</font>
:Y-axis:
+
:Y-axis: <font color="gray">
::<font color="gray">1 billion</font>
+
::1 billion
::<font color="gray">1 million</font>
+
::1 million
::<font color="gray">1,000</font>
+
::1,000
::<font color="gray">100</font>
+
::100
::<font color="gray">10</font>
+
::10
::<font color="gray">1</font>
+
::1</font>
 
:X-axis: <font color="gray">1960 1980 2000 2020</font>
 
:X-axis: <font color="gray">1960 1980 2000 2020</font>
  

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)