Editing 1786: Trash

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
[[Black Hat]] is, once again, thoroughly confusing [[Cueball]] (another example of this is [[908: The Cloud]]). This time, when inquired about a chute protruding from his wardrobe, Black Hat explains that it is a {{w|Chute_(gravity)#Building_chute|garbage chute}} into another dimension. Apparently these kinds of portals appear on about half of all the furniture that Black Hat buys, and he is somewhat annoyed about it. (This sounds more like something [[Beret Guy]] would encounter, although he would have reacted very differently than Black Hat.) It would be interesting to know whether all the portals lead into the same alternative world/dimension, but it seems Black Hat is not interested in visiting these worlds, instead just being annoyed about his broken furniture. (Given Black Hat's personality, this may well be a practical joke meant to mess with Cueball's head rather than an actual portal to another dimension.)
+
[[Black Hat]] is, once again, thoroughly confusing [[Cueball]], (like for instance in [[908: The Cloud]] and others). This time, when inquired about a chute protruding from his wardrobe, Black Hat explains that it is a {{w|Chute_(gravity)#Building_chute|garbage chute}} into another dimension. Apparently these kinds of portals appear on about half of all the furniture that Black Hat buys, and he is kinda annoyed about it. (This sounds more like something [[Beret Guy]] would encounter, although he would for sure have reacted very differently than Black Hat). It would be interesting to know whether all the portals lead into the same alternative world/dimension, but it seems Black Hat is not interested in visiting these worlds, but is just annoyed about his broken furniture.
  
Cueball quickly realizes this is a reference to ''{{w|The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe}}'', the first published book in {{w|The Chronicles of Narnia}} by {{w|C. S. Lewis}}. In the books, the child characters use different portals to get into the alternative dimension/world of {{w|Narnia}}. The children first find a portal inside an old wardrobe, and use it at least three times to travel into Narnia. Black Hat confirms his trash chute indeed leads to Narnia and explains how this is a great time-saver for him, as he can easily get rid of his trash. The Narnia books are for children and Narnia is a magical world, so Cueball is appalled to learn that Black Hat dumps his trash there.
+
Cueball quickly realizes this is a reference to ''{{w|The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe}}'' (which Black Hat confirms) the first book in {{w|The Chronicles of Narnia}} by {{w|C. S. Lewis}}. In the books the characters use different portals to get into {{w|Narnia}}. In the first book the children find the portal inside an old wardrobe, and they use it at least three times to travel into Narnia. The Narnia books are for children and Narnia is a magical world so Cueball is appalled to learn that Black Hat dumps his trash there.
  
A discussion of problems with this comic vs. Narnia chronology is discussed in the [[#Trivia|trivia section]].
+
Black Hat confirms that it is Narnia, and explains how this is a great time-saver for him, as he can easily get rid of his trash. A discussion of problems with this comic vs. Narnia chronology is discussed in the [[#Trivia|trivia section]].
  
The "huge cat" he refers to is {{w|Aslan}}, a magical lion in Narnia. In his lion form he sometimes walks around and watches over Narnia, but not all the time. It is revealed in the last book that he is also the guardian of the other worlds, where he has different names and takes on different appearances, implying he ''is'' Jesus, just in Narnia.
+
The "huge cat" he refers to is {{w|Aslan}}, a Magical lion that represents God in Narnia. In his Lion form he sometimes walks around in Narnia and he watches over Narnia, but not all the time. It is revealed in the last book that he is also the guardian of the other worlds, where he has different names and take on different appearances, so he is actually a representation of God, but always a benevolent God.
  
Aslan, or any other large cat or inhabitants of such a different world, would probably be really upset that someone is throwing their trash there{{Citation needed}}. He would probably try to stop this by any means necessary, including coming up through a trash chute into another dimension. But because lions are a type of cat (feline), apparently Aslan can be repelled with an ordinary spray bottle. The joke is that this is a technique used to tame small house cats; it would be unlikely to work on a lion, especially if the lion was really a deity{{Citation needed}}.
+
Aslan, or any other large cat or inhabitants of such a different world, would probably be really upset that someone is throwing their trash there. He would probably try to stop this by any means necessary, even if that means coming up through a trash chute into another dimension. But, because lions are a type of cat (feline), apparently he can be repelled with an ordinary spray bottle. The joke is this is a technique used to tame small house cats; it would be unlikely to work on a lion, especially if the lion was a representation of a deity.
  
In the title text, the fact that time passes much faster in Narnia than on Earth is mentioned. (Time does not pass at a constant rate compared to Earth time.) This could also be the case even if the portal in Black Hat's wardrobe accessed a different world than Narnia. So everything that is actually pushed to the other side of the portal would be disposed of very efficiently, as the trash could completely decompose within just a few Earth minutes. This would then explain how Black Hat can keep pushing more stuff into the other world: anything sent through the portal will decompose and vanish before he comes with his next load of trash.
+
In the title text the fact that time passes much faster in Narnia than on Earth is mentioned. (Time does not pass at a constant rate compared to Earth time.) This could also be the case even if Black Hat's world would be a different one than Narnia. So everything that is actually pushed to the other side of the portal would be disposed of very efficiently as within just a few Earth minutes, the trash could completely decompose. This would then explain how Black Hat can keep pushing more stuff into the other world. Anything getting over the border will vanish before he comes with his next trash bag.
  
The title text mention of {{w|Yucca Mountain}} is a reference to the {{w|Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository}}, a partially-built nuclear waste repository that has been defunded at the present time. Black Hat wants to contact those that wish to make such a repository and let them dispose of their radioactive waste through his "magical" portal, likely to make a profit for himself. If throwing trash into Narnia is terrible, radioactive waste would be far worse{{Citation needed}}. Of course in Earth time radioactive materials would soon decay back to background levels of radiation. This is thus another jab at all the world's environmental problems, as is also done with all the comics about [[:Category:Climate change|climate change]]. This comic could be a take on humans {{w|Marine_debris|dumping waste}} in the "endless" oceans, more specifically {{w|ocean disposal of radioactive waste}}. This was done in the past but is now banned, as Earth's oceans are not endless{{Citation needed}}.  
+
In the title text {{w|Yucca Mountain}} is mentioned. This is a reference to {{w|Yucca Mountain nuclear waste repository}}, a proposed nuclear waste repository that has been abandoned at present time. Black Hat wants to contact those that wish to make such a repository and let them dispose of their radioactive waste through his "magical" portal, likely to make a profit for himself. If throwing trash into Narnia is terrible, what then about radioactive waste... Of course in Earth time it would then soon have decayed to back ground levels... This is thus another jab at all the worlds environmental problems, in relation to all the comics about [[:Category:Climate change|climate change]]! This comic could be a take on humans {{w|Marine_debris|dumping waste}} in the "endless" oceans, more specifically {{w|Ocean disposal of radioactive waste}}. This was done excessively in the past but is now banned since Earths oceans are not endless.  
  
The title text copies the idea behind the {{w|Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal}} comic from
+
The title text copies the idea behind the {{w|Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal}} comic from  
[http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3513 October 15 2014]. The button at the bottom of that comic shows a sad {{w|Mr. Tumnus}}, a {{w|faun}} {{w|Lucy Pevensie|Lucy}} meets on her first visit to Narnia, rather than an angry Aslan as suggested in this comic.
+
[http://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=3513 October 15 2014]. The button at the bottom of the comic shows a sad {{w|Mr. Tumnus}}, the {{w|faun}} {{w|Lucy Pevensie|Lucy}} meets on her first visit to Narnia, rather than an angry Aslan as in this comic.
  
The portal through the wardrobe to Narnia was previously featured in [[665: Prudence]], [[969: Delta-P]] and [[821: Five-Minute Comics: Part 3]]. In the latter, the different passage of time was also mentioned.
+
The portal through the wardrobe to Narnia was previously featured in [[665: Prudence]] and [[969: Delta-P]], and the different passage of time was mentioned in [[821: Five-Minute Comics: Part 3]]).
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
:[Cueball looking at garbage chute attached to wardrobe. Black Hat answers him from off panel.]
+
:[Cueball looking at garbage chute attached to wardrobe. A Black Hat answers him from off panel.]
 
:Cueball: What's this thing on your wardrobe?
 
:Cueball: What's this thing on your wardrobe?
 
:Black Hat (off-panel): Garbage chute.
 
:Black Hat (off-panel): Garbage chute.
Line 43: Line 43:
 
==Trivia==
 
==Trivia==
 
*If one cares about the rules of the Narnia continuity...
 
*If one cares about the rules of the Narnia continuity...
**If the portal travels to Narnia specifically, this comic would have to be set during the books (that is to say, during the 1940's) because in the last book Narnia ceases to exist.  
+
**This comic would either have to be set during the books, because in the last book Narnia ceases to exist.  
 
**Note however in the continuity of the books, Narnia is not the only alternate world -- three of them are explored in ''The Magician's Nephew'' -- just the most famous to popular culture.
 
**Note however in the continuity of the books, Narnia is not the only alternate world -- three of them are explored in ''The Magician's Nephew'' -- just the most famous to popular culture.
 
***This other world could still also have Aslan, as implied in the books.
 
***This other world could still also have Aslan, as implied in the books.
Line 53: Line 53:
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Black Hat]]
 
[[Category:Comics featuring Black Hat]]
[[Category:Cats]]
+
[[Category:Fiction]]
 +
[[Category:Animals]]
 
[[Category:Time]]
 
[[Category:Time]]
[[Category:Chronicles of Narnia]]
 

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)