| Latest revision |
Your text |
| Line 4: |
Line 4: |
| | | title = ISO Paper Size Golden Spiral | | | title = ISO Paper Size Golden Spiral |
| | | image = iso_paper_size_golden_spiral.png | | | image = iso_paper_size_golden_spiral.png |
| − | | titletext = The ISO 216 standard ratio is cos(45°), but American letter paper is 8.5x11 because it uses radians, and 8.5/11 = pi/4. | + | | titletext = The ISO 216 standard ratio is cos(45°), but American letter paper is 8.5x11 because it uses radians, and 11/8.5 = pi/4. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | | |
| | ==Explanation== | | ==Explanation== |
| − | This is another comic on [[:Category:How to annoy|How to annoy]] people, here both graphic designers and mathematicians. This type of annoyance seems much like that displayed in [[590: Papyrus]] and [[1015: Kerning]].
| + | {{incomplete|Created by a GRAPHICS DESIGNER. Please mention here why this explanation isn't complete. Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}} |
| | | | |
| − | An easy way to annoy many mathematicians is to make fanciful claims about the {{w|Golden Ratio}}. It's been claimed, with varying levels of credibility, to be detectable in many natural and human-made situations, often with the dubious subjective claim that using the ratio in some particular way makes an image more "beautiful". The {{w|Golden Spiral}} is a spiral whose growth factor is this ratio; a common (though slightly geometrically inaccurate) way to illustrate the spiral is to draw curves through a set of squares whose side lengths shrink according to the Golden Ratio. The result looks rather like [[Randall|Randall's]] drawing here.
| + | This comic strip is about annoying graphics designers and mathematicians, much like [[590: Papyrus]] and [[1015: Kerning]]. |
| | | | |
| − | However, Randall hasn't used the Golden Ratio at all; he's just drawn a spiral (''not'' the Golden Spiral) through a common diagram showing the {{w|Paper size#A series|A Series}} of standard paper sizes, but in landscape instead of portrait (this diagram is commonly drawn in portrait). These papers aren't squares at all, but rectangles whose side lengths shrink by a factor of the square root of 2. Additionally, the paper sizes shrink by a factor of one half, so the area is filled in a geometric series. This is sometimes called a ''silver'' rectangle, although the {{w|Silver ratio}} is actually 1+√2. By mistaking the A Series for something connected with the Golden Ratio, ''and'' perpetuating the tradition of making dubious claims about the Golden Ratio, Randall has successfully annoyed both graphic designers and mathematicians.
| + | The [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_spiral Golden Spiral] is a figure made by concatenating squares whose side lengths shrink according to the golden ratio. One can make a similar shape with the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paper_size#A_series A Series] of standard paper sizes, but the figures are rectangles whose side lengths shrink by a factor of the square root of 2, not squares whose side lengths shrink by a factor of the golden ratio. This is meant to parody the numerous questionable examples of the golden ratio in everyday life. |
| | | | |
| − | The title text is a similarly themed joke, based partly on the fact that the US uses {{w|customary units}} while the vast majority of the rest of the world uses {{w|SI units}}. The 11/8.5 ratio is the length/width ratio of {{w|Letter (paper size)|US Letter}} paper, which is 11 inches by 8.5 inches (another common size in the United States is US Legal, which is 14" by 8.5"). The value of π/4 radians is indeed equal to 45 degrees, although Randall takes the cosine in one case and uses the raw angle in the other case in order to get a close coincidence of values. The width and length of A Series paper ({{w|ISO 216}}) is always given in whole millimeters, and the width/length ratio is very close to cos(45°) (which is 1/√2=0.707…) As for US Letter paper: to 4 decimal places, 8.5/11 = 0.7727 and π/4 = 0.7854. | + | The spiral shown is a logarithmic spiral with a growth factor of sqrt(2), and if the center of the spiral is at the origin, it may be graphed with r = C*2^(θ/π), for any positive constant C. |
| | | | |
| − | In reality, the usage of radians vs. degrees is not a geographic or political decision, but generally is delineated by profession. Most engineering and science fields measure angles in degrees or fractions of degrees (arcseconds, or even milliarcseconds in fields like astronomy), while mathematicians and physicists generally use radians. Civil engineers may refer to the slope of a road by its {{w|Grade (slope)|grade}}, which is commonly expressed in terms of the tangent of the angle to the horizontal (either as a percentage or a ratio); for angles up to ~10°, this is close to the value of the angle in radians.
| + | The mouse-over text is a joke, based partly on the fact that the US uses imperial units while much of the rest of the world uses S.I. units. The 11/8.5 ratio is the length/width ratio of US “letter” paper, which is 11 inches by 8.5 inches (not legal, US legal is 14 by 8.5). The value of pi/4 radians is indeed equal to 45 degrees, although Randall takes the cosine in one case and uses the raw angle in the other case in order to get a close coincidence of values. The width/length ratio of A series paper (ISO 216) is exactly cos(45 degrees), which is 1/sqrt(2). As for US letter paper, 11/8.5 is not in fact close to pi/4, but it’s possible that Randall meant to write 8.5/11 instead of 11/8.5. To 4 decimal places, 8.5/11 = 0.7727 and pi/4 = 0.7854. |
| | | | |
| − | The difference between the "real" Golden Spiral squares and Randall's version is approximately either .2038 (for √2-1.6180…) or .08907 ((1/√2)-1.6180…), depending on which way you're counting. Either way, the difference would be very noticeable.
| + | In reality, the usage of radians vs. degrees is not a geographic or political decision, but generally is delineated by profession. Most engineering and science fields measure angles in degrees or fractions of degrees (arcseconds, or even milliarcseconds in fields like astronomy), while mathematicians and physicists generally use radians. Civil engineers may refer to the slope of a road by its {{w|Grade (slope)|grade}}, which is commonly expressed in terms of the tangent of the angle to the horizontal (either as a percentage or a ratio); for angles up to ~10 degrees, this is close to the value of the angle in radians. |
| − | | |
| − | The spiral shown is approximately a logarithmic spiral with a growth factor of √2, although it has been edited slightly to make it fit neatly inside the rectangles.
| |
| − | If the center of the spiral is at the origin, it may be graphed with r = C*2^(θ/π), for any positive constant C.
| |
| − | | |
| − | In [[1488: Flowcharts]] a golden spiral has been laid in over the chart. That {{xkcd|1488|comic}} is a link that goes to the [https://xkcd.com/spiral/ spiral] page on xkcd.
| |
| | | | |
| | ==Transcript== | | ==Transcript== |
| Line 30: |
Line 25: |
| | | | |
| | :[Picture of the ISO standard paper sizes (i.e. A1, A2, etc.) placed so that they fit together perfectly, overlaid with a spiral resembling that of the golden ratio] | | :[Picture of the ISO standard paper sizes (i.e. A1, A2, etc.) placed so that they fit together perfectly, overlaid with a spiral resembling that of the golden ratio] |
| − | :[A rectangle in landscape orientation with width= height*sqrt(2) is divided into two halves by a vertical line. The left half, a rectangle in portrait orientation, with height=width*sqrt(2), is labeled "A1". The right half (also portrait) is divided into two halves by a horizontal line; the rectangle above this horizontal line (landscape) is labeled "A2". Below this horizontal line there is a landscape rectangle which is divided into two portrait rectangles by a vertical line. The right half is labeled "A3", the left half is divided into two halves by a horizontal line. The lower half is labeled "A4", the upper half is divided again, with its left half labeled "A5". The series continues like this until "A10". ]
| |
| − | :[Symbolically: A1 -right,up- A2 -down,right- A3 -left,down- A4 -up,left- A5 -right,up- A6 -down,right- A7 -left,down- A8 -up,left- A9 -right,up- A10.]
| |
| − | :[A red spiral starts at the lower left corner of A1, passes through the upper right corner of A1 which is also the upper left corner of A2, continues through the upper right corner of A3, lower right of A4, lower left of A5, etc, and after passing through the lower right corner of A10 continues to what would be the lower left corner of A11 and the upper right corner of A12.]
| |
| | | | |
| − | :[Caption below panel:] | + | :[Caption below panel:]<br /> |
| | :How to annoy both graphic designers and mathematicians | | :How to annoy both graphic designers and mathematicians |
| | | | |
| − | ==Trivia==
| + | {{incomplete transcript|Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}} |
| − | *The title text originally said 11/8.5 instead of 8.5/11. This has since been corrected.
| |
| | | | |
| | {{comic discussion}} | | {{comic discussion}} |
| − |
| |
| − | [[Category:Comics with color]]
| |
| − | [[Category:Math]]
| |
| − | [[Category:How to annoy]]
| |
