Editing 2456: Types of Scientific Paper

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 8: Line 8:
  
 
==Explanation==
 
==Explanation==
−
In this comic, Randall describes categories of scientific papers with somewhat humorous generalized titles. This comic may be a jab at mainstream news and their handling of scientific announcements; journalists are eager to report on what could turn out to be a scientific breakthrough even if it's very similar to stories they've already published about similar papers that turned out to be somewhat mundane. It may also relate to how some scientific findings follow certain patterns.
+
{{incomplete|Created by a RESEARCH DEPARTMENT ON A LUNCHBREAK. The explanation is one line of text and a table, the table's third row has empty cells, and the whole thing is generally in need of a little polish. Do NOT delete this tag too soon.}}
 +
In this comic, Randall describes categories of scientific papers with somewhat humorous generalized titles.
  
−
==Breakdown of papers==
+
==Table of papers==
 
{| class="wikitable"
 
{| class="wikitable"
 +
|+Breakdown of Papers
 
|-
 
|-
 
!Paper Title
 
!Paper Title
 
!Explanation
 
!Explanation
−
!Visual Description
+
!Article Description
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We put a camera somewhere new
 
!scope=row|We put a camera somewhere new
 
|This may involve miniaturisation or other improvements of imaging sensors, power supply, transmission or retention of data, environmental hardening and (possibly) recovery afterwards. Photographs and videos can be especially helpful in understanding what is or was going on, especially for the layman, than more limited signal traces.
 
|This may involve miniaturisation or other improvements of imaging sensors, power supply, transmission or retention of data, environmental hardening and (possibly) recovery afterwards. Photographs and videos can be especially helpful in understanding what is or was going on, especially for the layman, than more limited signal traces.
  
−
Cameras have been inserted into every obvious bodily orifice (including swallowed, to be later excreted), placed in habitats to monitor wildlife, attached to wildlife to monitor habitats, sent into volcanic craters/ocean trenches/high altitudes/nuclear reactors, launched into space and sent past/round/onto several of the solar-system's more interesting bodies. This makes the "somewhere new" claim intriguing, possibly even comparable to 'clickbait'.
+
Cameras have been inserted into ''every'' obvious bodily orifice (including swallowed, to be later excreted), placed in habitats to monitor wildlife, attached to wildlife to monitor habitats, sent into volcanic craters/ocean trenches/high altitudes/nuclear reactors, launched into space and sent past/round/onto several of the solar-system's more interesting bodies. This makes the "somewhere new" claim intriguing, possibly even comparable to 'clickbait'.<br/>This could also be generalized even more by replacing "camera" with "sensor", and then going to debate the newly derived sensor data.
−
 
 
−
This could also be generalized even more by replacing "camera" with "sensor", and then going to debate the newly derived sensor data.  
 
 
|Includes a large figure, likely an image captured with the camera.
 
|Includes a large figure, likely an image captured with the camera.
 
|-
 
|-
Line 30: Line 30:
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|My colleague is wrong and I can finally prove it
 
!scope=row|My colleague is wrong and I can finally prove it
−
|This title refers to the occasional rivalries between scientists within a field, which can push them to seek proof that they, and not their colleague, are correct. This search for vindication, rather than truth, can lead the researcher to overlook significant flaws in their research, and can also make for tedious reading. It reflects a tone of smug self-satisfaction.
+
|This title refers to the occasional rivalries between scientists within a field, which can push them to seek proof that they, and not their colleague, are correct. It reflects a tone of smug self-satisfaction.
−
|Like the two previous types, this one is laid out in two-column format with occasional section headings. Unlike those types, it has no figures.
+
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|The immune system is at it again
 
!scope=row|The immune system is at it again
−
|The human immune system is notoriously complex, and there are countless papers in medical fields just describing its strangeness. While it is best known for preventing and battling infections, it can also overreact or even turn against the body that it is supposed to protect. Moreover it can overreact, for instance in allergic reactions or in a potentially lethal {{w|cytokine storm}} known to occur in certain viral infections, including {{w|influenza}} and {{w|COVID-19}}. The title may convey exasperation with the amorphous nature of this study subject.
+
|The human immune system is notoriously complex, and there are countless papers in medical fields just describing its strangeness. While it is best known for preventing and battling infections, in auto-immune disease, it can also turn against the body that it is supposed to protect. Moreover it can overreact, for instance in allergic reactions or in a potentially lethal {{w|cytokine storm}} known to occur in certain viral infections, including {{w|Influenza}} and {{w|COVID-19}}. The title may convey exasperation with the amorphous nature of their study subject.  
−
|Two-column format, no figures.
+
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We figured out how to make this exotic material, so email us if you need some
 
!scope=row|We figured out how to make this exotic material, so email us if you need some
 
|Researchers often attempt to create materials despite there not being any demand, predicting that in the future their material will be game-changing without any actual applications. These researchers have created such a material, and are offering to produce it for anyone who needs it. It is couched in terms of having created an answer for which there was not yet any proper question.
 
|Researchers often attempt to create materials despite there not being any demand, predicting that in the future their material will be game-changing without any actual applications. These researchers have created such a material, and are offering to produce it for anyone who needs it. It is couched in terms of having created an answer for which there was not yet any proper question.
−
 
+
This may be also referring to the discovering/creating of elements and subatomic particles. The statement if you wish to buy it is humorous in these cases because they will decay too quickly to be purchased.
−
Sometimes the only reason for trying to create the materials is that they are peculiar or novel in some way, with no consideration of whether they might have any use apart from demonstrating the novel property. However, some other people might find that property very useful... and may lack the ability to make the substance for themselves.
+
|
−
 
 
−
This may be also referring to the discovering/creating of elements and subatomic particles. The statement if you wish to buy it is humorous in these cases because they will decay too quickly to be purchased.
 
−
|Two-column format, no figures.
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|What are fish even doing down there
 
!scope=row|What are fish even doing down there
Line 51: Line 48:
  
 
Whichever way, the title probably reflects a totally unexpected result that is possibly too cross-disciplinary to be properly comprehended as an actual scientific advance by the authors. However, a proper study of the species could very well be an important paper.
 
Whichever way, the title probably reflects a totally unexpected result that is possibly too cross-disciplinary to be properly comprehended as an actual scientific advance by the authors. However, a proper study of the species could very well be an important paper.
−
|This one-column paper does not appear to have any headers, implying a longer, free-flowing format.
+
|This paper does not appear to have any headers, implying a longer, free-flowing format.
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|This task I had to do anyway turned out to be hard enough for its own paper
 
!scope=row|This task I had to do anyway turned out to be hard enough for its own paper
Line 57: Line 54:
  
 
The author may be glad to have been able to turn mundane 'housekeeping' activities, that don't normally do much to enhance academic reputations, into an actual opportunity to be cite-worthy.
 
The author may be glad to have been able to turn mundane 'housekeeping' activities, that don't normally do much to enhance academic reputations, into an actual opportunity to be cite-worthy.
−
|This paper is also one-column but it contains section headers.
+
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|Hey, at least we showed that this method can produce results! That's not nothing, right?
 
!scope=row|Hey, at least we showed that this method can produce results! That's not nothing, right?
Line 63: Line 60:
  
 
In this case, the authors may otherwise have worked on their problem and been left with no citable proof of their efforts. The title perhaps reflects an attempt to present this as 'success' of a different kind, rather than a submission to such a null/negative-results platform. This may be similar to the above type of paper too.
 
In this case, the authors may otherwise have worked on their problem and been left with no citable proof of their efforts. The title perhaps reflects an attempt to present this as 'success' of a different kind, rather than a submission to such a null/negative-results platform. This may be similar to the above type of paper too.
−
|Two-column format, no figures.
+
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|Check out this weird thing one of us saw while out for a walk
 
!scope=row|Check out this weird thing one of us saw while out for a walk
 
|This paper may be imagined as an opportunistic publication. A department or team has seen itself low down on the local 'league table' for academic output. A brainstorming session for a way of rectifying this led to desperately seizing upon the first idle comment made (in lieu of any better sounding ideas) that can somehow be shoehorned into their respective subject area, and is now being presented similar to "this one weird thing" clickbait titles that almost always oversell their content.
 
|This paper may be imagined as an opportunistic publication. A department or team has seen itself low down on the local 'league table' for academic output. A brainstorming session for a way of rectifying this led to desperately seizing upon the first idle comment made (in lieu of any better sounding ideas) that can somehow be shoehorned into their respective subject area, and is now being presented similar to "this one weird thing" clickbait titles that almost always oversell their content.
−
This also works in the context of entomology. Insects have the most species of any class of animals [https://www.si.edu/spotlight/buginfo/bugnos by a wide margin], but due to their small size, they're not easily seen. As a result, new species are constantly being discovered in places as innocuous as [https://wildlife.org/video-entomologists-discover-30-new-species-in-la-backyards/ someone's backyard].
+
 
 +
This also works in the context of entomology. Insects have the most species of any class of animals [https://www.si.edu/spotlight/buginfo/bugnos by a wide margin], but due to their small size, they're not easily seen. As a result, new species are constantly being discovered in places as innocuous as [https://wildlife.org/video-entomologists-discover-30-new-species-in-la-backyards/ someone's backyard.]
  
 
It also works in botany, especially floristics. Papers of first records of alien plants refer to weird things botanists saw on walks. Vagrant birds, unusual animal behaviour, and strange meteorological phenomena are other subcategories.
 
It also works in botany, especially floristics. Papers of first records of alien plants refer to weird things botanists saw on walks. Vagrant birds, unusual animal behaviour, and strange meteorological phenomena are other subcategories.
−
|Two-column layout. Includes several large figures, likely close-up photographs of the weird thing. There are no headers, as the paper may have little background or methodology, just observations.
+
|Includes several large figures, likely close-up photographs of the weird thing. There are no headers, as the paper may have little background or methodology, just observations.
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We are 500 scientists and here's what we've been up to for the last 10 years
 
!scope=row|We are 500 scientists and here's what we've been up to for the last 10 years
−
|Some papers summarize the work of big research teams, like those working on the [https://repositorio.uc.cl/xmlui/bitstream/handle/11534/13948/Observation%20of%20a%20new%20particle%20in%20the%20search%20for%20the%20Standard%20Model%20Higgs%20boson%20with%20the%20ATLAS%20detector%20at%20the%20LHC.pdf Higgs Boson] (list of authors starts at page 17 and goes to page 26 with foot notes about authors to page 29, and a dedication in the header would suggest that more than one other contributor <i>died</i> over the course of the research, which would be rather unusual for a smaller project) or LIGO. Since the discoveries which are made are a team effort, probably outlasting many of the individual tenures involved, the papers have many authors listed.
+
| Some papers summarize the work of big research teams, like those working on the [https://repositorio.uc.cl/xmlui/bitstream/handle/11534/13948/Observation%20of%20a%20new%20particle%20in%20the%20search%20for%20the%20Standard%20Model%20Higgs%20boson%20with%20the%20ATLAS%20detector%20at%20the%20LHC.pdf Higgs Boson] (list of authors starts at page 17 and goes to page 26 with foot notes about authors to page 29, and a dedication in the header would suggest that more than one other contributor ''died'' over the course of the research, which would be rather unusual for a smaller project) or LIGO. Since the discoveries which are made are a team effort, probably outlasting many of the individual tenures involved, the papers have many authors listed.
 
A credit for participation may not mean any particularly great contribution by each individual, but being left out (even for one summer's secondment, seven years before any results could be recorded) would be taken as a slight, and an opportunity missed to be 'citable' in the future.
 
A credit for participation may not mean any particularly great contribution by each individual, but being left out (even for one summer's secondment, seven years before any results could be recorded) would be taken as a slight, and an opportunity missed to be 'citable' in the future.
 
|A huge portion of the page is taken up by the presumably 500 authors' names, above the main horizontal bar.
 
|A huge portion of the page is taken up by the presumably 500 authors' names, above the main horizontal bar.
Line 79: Line 77:
 
!scope=row|Some thoughts on how everyone else is bad at research
 
!scope=row|Some thoughts on how everyone else is bad at research
 
|Similar to the "my colleague is wrong" paper, but in this case applied to far greater swathes of the community by the author(s) of this (possibly unfocused) tract. Usually a "systematic review", the words 'some thoughts' might indicate a meta-approach with no original research - and possibly a passive-aggressive style of assessment.
 
|Similar to the "my colleague is wrong" paper, but in this case applied to far greater swathes of the community by the author(s) of this (possibly unfocused) tract. Usually a "systematic review", the words 'some thoughts' might indicate a meta-approach with no original research - and possibly a passive-aggressive style of assessment.
−
|No header sections, possibly because these particular thoughts are in the form of an essay or letter without an accompanying investigation. Formatting this article as a single column with large blocks of text could also be indicating a slightly unhinged rant by someone who&mdash;wrongly&mdash;perceives themselves as unjustly marginalized.
+
|No header sections, possibly because these particular thoughts are in the form of an essay or letter without an accompanying investigation. Formatting this article as a single column with large blocks of text could also be indicating a slightly unhinged rant by someone who - wrongly - perceives themselves as unjustly marginalised.
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We scanned some undergraduates
 
!scope=row|We scanned some undergraduates
 
|Initial research is often done at universities, so when human subjects are required, recruiting undergraduate students is a common, easy, and inexpensive way to gather enough people to conduct studies or experiments. This is extremely common in psychological or sociological studies, but can involve more medical (but non-invasive) 'scans', from simple eyeball-tracking to full-body MRI. This practice is often criticized, as it introduces a selection bias, which makes the results difficult to generalize to the entire population, as university students in a given country are not necessarily a representative sample of human beings as a whole. Nonetheless, easy accessibility makes these students a source of data for many academic papers. The low-key approach to the title (concentrating blandly upon the method with no references to results) may indicate that the results obtained are very trivial and no great developments were even made in implementation. Alternately, this is a truly ground-breaking paper obscured entirely by the lead author's over-narrow professional focus and avoidance of any hype.
 
|Initial research is often done at universities, so when human subjects are required, recruiting undergraduate students is a common, easy, and inexpensive way to gather enough people to conduct studies or experiments. This is extremely common in psychological or sociological studies, but can involve more medical (but non-invasive) 'scans', from simple eyeball-tracking to full-body MRI. This practice is often criticized, as it introduces a selection bias, which makes the results difficult to generalize to the entire population, as university students in a given country are not necessarily a representative sample of human beings as a whole. Nonetheless, easy accessibility makes these students a source of data for many academic papers. The low-key approach to the title (concentrating blandly upon the method with no references to results) may indicate that the results obtained are very trivial and no great developments were even made in implementation. Alternately, this is a truly ground-breaking paper obscured entirely by the lead author's over-narrow professional focus and avoidance of any hype.
−
|Two-column format with figures.
+
|
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We've incrementally improved the estimate of this coefficient
 
!scope=row|We've incrementally improved the estimate of this coefficient
Line 101: Line 99:
 
|-
 
|-
 
!scope=row|We found a way to make student volunteers worse at tasks
 
!scope=row|We found a way to make student volunteers worse at tasks
−
|Possibly a psychology experiment, and maybe not even the result expected. In general, the repetition of an activity will induce greater skill/capacity in a tested individual. By accident or design, the study group in this instance has induced the opposite correlation. (There are, however, some studies that explicitly look at how e.g. lack of sleep reduces productivity.)
+
|Possibly a psychology experiment, and maybe not even the result expected. In general, the repetition of an activity will induce greater skill/capacity in a tested individual. By accident or design, the study group in this instance has induced the opposite correlation. (There ''are'', however, some studies that explicitly look at how e.g. lack of sleep reduces productivity.)
  
 
Exactly what emotion the title reflects might depend upon whether the worsening was an intended result, or even how the team were able to refocus and seize upon the adverse outcomes.
 
Exactly what emotion the title reflects might depend upon whether the worsening was an intended result, or even how the team were able to refocus and seize upon the adverse outcomes.
Line 107: Line 105:
  
 
==Transcript==
 
==Transcript==
 +
{{incomplete transcript|Could need description of each paper}}
 
:[Heading:]
 
:[Heading:]
 
:Types of Scientific Paper  
 
:Types of Scientific Paper  
  
−
:[An array of 4 rows with 3 scientific papers each, is shown. We see the first page of each paper, but only its title is legible. Headings are shown as black lines, paragraphs of text are shown as several squiggly lines and figures are shown as empty white rectangles. Titles are as follows:]
+
:[An array of 4 rows with 3 scientific papers each, is shown. The first page of each is shown, but only the papers titles are legible. Black lines for headings, several lines for paragraphs of text and white rectangles indicating figures are used to make each paper look different. Titles are as follows:]
 
:We put a camera somewhere new
 
:We put a camera somewhere new
 
:Hey, I found a trove of old records! They don't turn out to be particularly useful, but still, cool!
 
:Hey, I found a trove of old records! They don't turn out to be particularly useful, but still, cool!
Line 126: Line 125:
 
==Trivia==
 
==Trivia==
 
*Originally, this comic's title text misspelled "volunteers" as "volunters".  
 
*Originally, this comic's title text misspelled "volunteers" as "volunters".  
 +
**This could have been intentional (''we'' might be the volunteers)
 +
**But it was not as it was quickly corrected.
 
*Another comic, [[2012: Thorough Analysis]], similarly categorizes or mocks research papers.
 
*Another comic, [[2012: Thorough Analysis]], similarly categorizes or mocks research papers.
  
 
==Derivatives==
 
==Derivatives==
 
The comic inspired many derivatives, changing the paper titles to be more relevant to specific fields.  
 
The comic inspired many derivatives, changing the paper titles to be more relevant to specific fields.  
−
 
+
The hashtag #TypesOfScientificPapers on twitter includes many of these.
−
The hashtag [https://twitter.com/search?q=%23TypesOfScientificPapers&src=typed_query&f=live #TypesOfScientificPapers] on Twitter includes many of these.
 
−
 
 
 
There is a [https://observablehq.com/@guillaume-levrier/xkcd-types-paper generator].
 
There is a [https://observablehq.com/@guillaume-levrier/xkcd-types-paper generator].
−
 
−
There is a [https://app.milanote.com/1LDuH91krMUK9z moodboard compiling hundreds of them].
 
  
 
Some examples include:
 
Some examples include:
Line 214: Line 211:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| https://twitter.com/jonathanagray/status/1388527626495594504  || Media studies
 
| https://twitter.com/jonathanagray/status/1388527626495594504  || Media studies
−
|-
 
−
| https://twitter.com/awaisaftab/status/1388133087356325888    || Psychiatry
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| https://twitter.com/OriPomson/status/1388911680277651462      || International Humanitarian Law (aka 'Law of Armed Conflicts')
 
| https://twitter.com/OriPomson/status/1388911680277651462      || International Humanitarian Law (aka 'Law of Armed Conflicts')
Line 222: Line 217:
 
{{comic discussion}}
 
{{comic discussion}}
  
−
[[Category:Scientific research]]
+
[[Category:Research Papers]]
 
[[Category:Science]]
 
[[Category:Science]]

Please note that all contributions to explain xkcd may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource (see explain xkcd:Copyrights for details). Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To protect the wiki against automated edit spam, we kindly ask you to solve the following CAPTCHA:

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page:

Retrieved from "https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/2456:_Types_of_Scientific_Paper"