3324: Ultimate Movie Series

explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
(Redirected from 3324)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Ultimate Movie Series
Sadly, none of the 14 Land Before Time films manage to make the list, although a small but devoted fan contingent argues that The Great Longneck Migration should beat out Guardians of the Galaxy.
Title text: Sadly, none of the 14 Land Before Time films manage to make the list, although a small but devoted fan contingent argues that The Great Longneck Migration should beat out Guardians of the Galaxy.

Explanation[edit]

This is one of 73 incomplete explanations:
This page was THE FOURTEENTH PART OF A MOVIE SERIES TO BE RELEASED SOON. I don't think this is Randall's opinion. I think he uses IMDb, which would certainly fit with the Godfather and the other in the first part of the list. But maybe someone with time could check if this could be true for at least the first 6-7 movies. Don't remove this notice too soon. You can help by editing the explanation!

This comic lists fifteen films from several different movie franchises, combined into a single "ultimate movie series". Randall has selected each entry in the series by comparing the movies that occupy the corresponding slot in their own series and choosing the one that he considers the best movie. For example, for the first slot, he would compare movies like The Godfather, Star Wars / A New Hope, The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, Star Trek: The Motion Picture, and so on. This is absurd, since the movies are unrelated and, especially later on, heavily dependent on previous movies that are not present in the list, so watching them as a 'series' in this way would be incomprehensible.

The title text mentions The Land Before Time series, a franchise consisting of animated adventure films centered around dinosaurs, but states that none of the 14 films would beat out any of the films already listed. However, there is a "devoted fanbase" for the 10th film (The Land Before Time X: The Great Longneck Migration), who believe that it is better than any other 10th installment of a series.

No. Movie Franchise Total in franchise Notes
1 The Godfather (1972) The Godfather 3 The 1st film in Francis Ford Coppola’s Godfather trilogy. It is widely considered to be one of the greatest films of all time.
2 The Empire Strikes Back (1980) Star Wars 12 The Empire Strikes Back, while subtitled as "Episode V", was the second Star Wars film to release. It is often regarded as the best in the series and among the greatest films ever made; the place on the listing implies Randall believes it to specifically be the greatest direct sequel, as the second entry, of any franchise.
3 Return of the King (2003) The Lord of the Rings 3 The 3rd film in Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy (and the 3rd live-action Middle-earth film released).
4 Fury Road (2015) Mad Max 5 The 4th installment in George Miller’s Mad Max franchise (following Mad Max, The Road Warrior, and Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome).
5 Prey (2022) Predator 7 The 5th solo/mainline Predator film, after Predator, Predator 2, Predators, and The Predator.
6 Fallout (2018) Mission: Impossible 8 The 6th film in the Mission: Impossible franchise.
7 The Force Awakens (2015) Star Wars 12 The second Star Wars film in the list, Episode VII: The Force Awakens was generally well-received. In watching the ultimate movie series, a viewer would likely be confused due to the absence of the film Episode VI: Return of the Jedi between Empire and The Force Awakens.
8 First Contact (1996) Star Trek 13 The 8th movie in the franchise overall, and the second of the Next Generation-era films.
9 Badlands (2025) Predator 9 Including the two Alien vs. Predator crossover films, Badlands is the ninth, rather than the seventh, Predator film.
10 Guardians of the Galaxy (2014) Marvel Cinematic Universe 38+ The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) is an extremely expansive series of movies and television shows that has made active releases since 2008. Guardians of the Galaxy is the tenth such film, even though it is the first in its own sub-trilogy containing Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 and Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3. It was better-received than many other films in the franchise's Phase Two.
The Great Longneck Migration (2003) The Land Before Time 14 (title text; see above) The tenth installment of the adventure musical franchise, and the ninth direct-to-video one.
11 Star Trek (2009) Star Trek 13 The 11th Star Trek feature film overall (following six Original Series films and four Next Generation films) and the first in the "Kelvin Timeline" reboot.
12 Moonraker (1979) James Bond 27 The 12th James Bond feature film released if you include the non-Eon 1967 comedy Casino Royale (it is the 11th official Eon Productions Bond film).
13 Beyond (2016) Star Trek 13 The 13th Star Trek feature film overall (and the 3rd in the J.J. Abrams-produced reboot series).
14 Doctor Strange (2016) Marvel Cinematic Universe 38+ The 14th film released in the MCU (following Captain America: Civil War).
15 Air Bud Returns (2027)(presumably) Air Bud 14 The comic asserts that the relatively low-stakes and still unreleased Air Bud Returns will be the best 15th movie of any franchise. Few franchises have reached 15 films, but contenders that Air Bud Returns supposedly defeats include the well-received Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (MCU) and Never Say Never Again (James Bond).

Transcript[edit]

This is one of 43 incomplete transcripts:
Don't remove this notice too soon. Qewdesyg tried helping, but I don't know if I should remove this now. You can help by editing the transcript!

[A header:] The Ultimate Movie Series
[A subheader:] Constructed by taking the best Nth installment from any franchise:
[A series of rows featuring film names, in the form of just the film's subtitle in cases where the main series title in the name can be inferred. Each of these is preceded by a Roman-numeral signifying the (released) position of the named film, within its nominal series. A couple of entries feature parenthetical clarifications/comments.]
I: The Godfather
II: The Empire Strikes Back
III: Return of the King
IV: Fury Road
V: Prey
VI: Fallout
VII: The Force Awakens
VIII: First Contact
IX: Badlands
X: Guardians of the Galaxy
XI: Star Trek (JJ Abrams)
XII: Moonraker
XIII: Beyond
XIV: Doctor Strange
XV: Air Bud Returns (2027) (presumably)


  Add comment 

Discussion

Thou is thread sniping 2a02:c7c:eefd:cd00:8c33:15b7:4ce9:ff7a (talk) 10:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

please sign your comments--TicTac_ :P (talk) 16:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Movies Referenced

I'm confused, what are the 15 Air Bud movies? I'm looking at the Wikipedia article you linked and the list says Air Bud Returns *will* be the 15th. Unless Wiki is missing a movie I think Randall is just right about this and the only joke is that Air Bud wins. Nezumi (talk) 18:04, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I see 6 Air Bud, 7 Air Buddies, and 2 Santa Paws movies. That adds up to 15 total. Barmar (talk) 21:26, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
That list includes Air Bud Returns. Nezumi (talk) 15:52, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Putting an JJ Abrams movie as the best Star Trek movie feels like a hate crime against Trekkies /2A07:5CC0:43A0:1B00:EA6A:64FF:FE38:C974 18:37, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

That does not mean that it is the best Star Trek movie; it means that of all movie series with 11 or more entries, this is the best "episode 11". That is, the comparison is against the 11th Bond movie and the 11 MCU movie, etc. --Itub (talk) 20:09, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Think on the bright side: even after JJ got his meddling hands into the series and caused the destruction of Romulus and the splitting of timelines (spoilers!), Star Trek is still awesome enough to beat out all the other candidates. 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 00:14, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Well one of the other candidates, by Randall's counting, would be "The Spy who Loved me" which is generally considered to be one of the better Bond movies. In contrast to "Moonraker", which made the list. Hm. But then again, "Moonraker" would be only up against Start Trek Into Darkness and Avengers Age of Ultron ... Maybe he did not want to have two James Bond movies in a row. --2A02:8071:B84:FE60:90BC:5F6C:703C:F191 00:30, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Hm indeed. Or maybe it was Randall's preference for science fiction in general; we aren't told how he defines best anyway - though Star Trek did get 94% on RT and The Spy Who Loved Me got 82%. (Small note: you forgot to consider Spooky Buddies and Treasure Buddies, not like that means much *traumatic shudder*) 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 03:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Struth. The emperor's new Godfather. Well, once that's been invoked, nobody's allowed to say anything, are they? Even though it's...OK. It's weird. If you say you don't like the Godfather, you automatically discredit your opinion. You can't be trusted to have a reasonable opinion about the Godfather because you don't like the Godfather. It's the best, so if you say it's not, you're wrong – obviously: you just proved it by saying the Godfather is not the best! Stands to reason! Etc. Dislike the Godfather and you're immediately plunged into a storyline by Kafka. Yorkshire Pudding (talk) 19:00, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

TIL that there are 1300% more "Air bud" movies than I thought… Fabian42 (talk) 21:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

It might seem a bit inconsistent that Randall counts "Prey" as a 5th movie (excluding the two AvP movies) but "Badlands" as a 9th (obviously INcluding the two AvP movies). Then again, "Badlands" is technically an AvP movie, too, so it seems to make sense to include the two others. But.... shouldn't he then also include all the Alien movies that came before? --2A02:8071:B84:FE60:90BC:5F6C:703C:F191 00:40, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Graphical analysis, with Rotten Tomato scores

For context, here's another way of looking at it. Green cells are the comic's 'selected' ones, but only in the context given by the comic. Yellow cells are 'YMMV'/pending members of the series concerned, whether necessary for the comic to work or not. Values (which you can click/hover over to find out what the film actually is!) are the Rotten Tomato percentage approvals that I could find documented (may not equal current RT site numbers!), as the most consistent value I could use for (mostly) every possible example, with "?" being unrated (sort value of zeo), * for one example with not technically enough ratings to be useful, and "..." (sort value of -1) being not-yet-ratable. E&OE.

Series Series# Noted 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th 11th 12th 13th 14th 15th 16th 17th 18th 19th 20th 21st 22nd 23rd 24th 25th 26th 27th 28th 29th 30th 31st 32nd 33rd 34th 35th 36th 37th 38th 39th 40th 41st 42nd 43rd
Godfather 3(ish) #1 97 96 66 86
LOTR 3-6 #3 92 95 94 64 75 59
Mad Max 5 #4 90 94 79 97 90
Predator (no Alien) 7 #5 64 36 65 34 94 95 86
Mission Impossible 8 #6 65 57 73 94 94 98 96 80
Predator (inc. Alien) 9 #9 64 36 21 12 65 34 94 95 86
Star Wars 9 #2,#7 93 93 84 54 62 79 93 91 51
Star Wars + 13 - 93 93 84 54 62 79 18 93 84 91 69 51 61
Star Trek 14 #8,#11,#13 51 87 78 82 22 83 47 93 55 37 94 84 86 24
Star Trek (only 'even' films!) 7 - 87 82 83 93 37 84 24
Airbud 14+1 #15 48 21 50* - - 64 - - - - - - 54 - …
James Bond 27 #12 28 95 97 99 85 73 81 64 67 40 82 59 69 41 71 36 75 79 81 58 51 55 94 63 92 63 83
James Bond (Eon) 25 - 95 97 99 85 73 81 64 67 40 82 59 69 41 36 75 79 81 58 51 55 94 63 92 63 83
MCU >38 #10,#14 94 68 72 77 80 91 79 67 90 91 75 83 90 89 85 92 93 96 85 87 79 94 91 79 92 48 93 73 64 83 48 82 63 77 46 88 86 90 … … … … …

...pondered adding more series(es) to that. Matrix (c.f. 566) and Highlander (there can be only one!) among them. 89.243.29.144 19:43, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

This is great. I can see that it fits perfectly with the series included, so that the chosen one is always the one with best rating. But yes other series should be included as well to make this work. Great work. Kynde (talk) 21:02, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Well, the 'green' is often, but not always, the best of its column (as you can see by sorting any particular column and seeing where the green sits). And in some cases isn't even a contender, especially Airbud's #15 that has no value. There's other measures (metacritic, imdb, etc) that might work better to match Randall's vision - and I'm not sure that Randall even based his list on any actual rankings... Personal preferences plus maybe an 'oddball' inclusion just for laughs, probably.
This was really just my own vision. I spreadsheeted it and only really decided to convert it to wikitable earlier today. It is too wide for the Explanation, for one thing, though I made each 'movie' cell just the number of percent in order to keep it thinner than anything else that might have been in the respective cells.
I might have added various other sets of films:
  • Land Before Time, for obvious titletext reasons;
  • Alien and Alien-with-Predator rows would complement the (pure) Predator and Predator-with-Alien ones
  • Back To The Futures
  • Die Hard / Bourne / John Wick / Jack Reacher / that sort of thing
  • Police Academy / Beverley Hill Cop / Naked Gun / Austin Powers, at least for the lulz
  • Wallace & Grommit series.
  • Godzilla (Toho and/or recent Hollywood eras)
  • Muppets movies
  • Canonball Runs / Gumball Rallies / Smokey And The Bandits
  • All the Batmans, All the Supermans (including the crossovers/pair-ups) and/or official DCEU as a whole, also maybe all the Spidermans (inc. Venoms?) even those outside the already stated MCU.
  • Halloween, Nightmare On Elm Street and/or Hellraiser. The set of The Omen films. The Exorcist. Leprechaun.
  • Harry Potter/Fantastic Beasts.
  • Charlie Chan films. "The Road to..." films (Bing Crosby, Bob Hope).
  • "Carry On..."s. "Confessions of a..."s.
  • Maybe Marx Brothers / Three Stooges / Laurel & Hardy / Charlie Chaplin / Buster Keaton / Harold Lloyd
  • Fistful Of Dollars and its followups, The Magnificent Seven etc (including Seven Samurai?)
  • ...and that's just (mostly!) the Anglosphere. For others, something like Fantozzi, maybe? ;)
But that would take a lot of work to properly do, and wouldn't really have a end-condition for.
(Also, I might ask for a nice template to streamline the cells, something like {{filmCell|<title for {{w}} link>|RT=<RT score, optional!>|highlight=[yes|maybe]<optional!>}}, as it was so easy to make trivial errors with too few or too many |s, etc, when I first transcribed that... If we're going to make it a fuller 'grand project'. But I can't see that actually being necessary, as it's going well beyond scope.)
But really this was just for interest. Mostly mine, but thought it'd be worth mentioning here. 89.243.29.144 22:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

This is how I learned how stupid RT ratings are. Star Wars Episode 7 actually has the same rating as episodes 4 and 5. Episode 8 only has 2 points less. I didn't think anyone actually thought 8 was good. Maybe the Star Wars fans rated it high because they couldn't bear to admit that their franchise had gotten bad, and the non fans rated it high because, I dunno, it had flashy lights? But seriously. I feel like I just stepped into a mirror dimension. Nezumi (talk) 01:28, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

The RT scores shown in WP articles, the main one, is the the critics' score and not the audience score, which probably explains the discrepancy. 7amiþ = moi.__init__(t, c) 01:43, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
My memory is that the reaction to The Last Jedi was the opposite: it was the hardcore fans who disliked it, because they had some preconceived idea of what Star Wars should be. Taken without that purist vision, it has some interesting new ideas, and sets up intriguing mysteries - all of which was thrown away when The Rise of Skywalker lurched hard back to the "traditional" camp. Of the three sequels, it's easily my favourite - The Force Awakens was a fun remake of A New Hope; The Rise of Skywalker was bad fan-fiction. - IMSoP (talk) 14:51, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
IMDB ratings are a much more accurate assessment of a movie's overall value (entertainment, artistic, etc). Most importantly because they are living and can change over time, whereas an RT rating is mostly a fixed window of contemporary reviews.Sturmovik (talk) 19:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Fill your boots, if you wish to check every film in any other rating system. Possibly out of date RT scores (and "approval rating" percentage, rather than "average rating" out of 10) were just the most convenient semi-representative thing to note down, with the exception of those instances where I had to actually go and check whether or not there was such a value. (Without looking for similarly current values for every other 'already recorded' case.) If I can try to clarify, I put far more work in establishing the identities of every item in every relevant (or adjacent-to-relevant) list than doing a full meta-analysis of which set of subjective data is at least partially consistently objective. 81.179.196.52 21:12, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
What about The Clone Wars as the 7th Star War? And is TFA really better than Harry Potter 7 anyway? I guess Randall wanted to make a joke about putting it out of order though. Might have been funny to put Harry Potter 7 II as #8 though. I'd also argue for Muppets Christmas Carol (could be as the pure Muppets only franchise or a Henson-verse including Yoda, Labrinyth, etc.) and Aladdin (in the Disney Princess franchise) Also kind of sad not to include any Fast and The Furious Movies. 136.226.19.62 21:58, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
        Add comment