Difference between revisions of "3238: Soniferous Aether"
| (9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
==Explanation== | ==Explanation== | ||
{{incomplete|This page was created recently by a BOT THAT BREATHES SONIFEROUS AETHER. Don't remove this notice too soon.}} | {{incomplete|This page was created recently by a BOT THAT BREATHES SONIFEROUS AETHER. Don't remove this notice too soon.}} | ||
| + | This comic makes a joke on the {{w|speed of light}} and the {{w|speed of sound}}, and the way in which speed and light travel. | ||
| − | + | Beginning in the late 1690s, scientists posited a {{w|luminiferous aether}} to explain properties of light (especially its ability to travel in a vacuum) which should not be possible for a wave. The 1887 {{w|Michelson–Morley experiment}} disproved its existence, and nowadays this property is explained by {{w|wave–particle duality}}, which says that light can act as both a particle and a wave. | |
| − | + | In this comic, [[Cueball]] & [[Ponytail]] are also sudgesting a {{w|luminous aether}} for the speed of sound instead. However, this 'aether' is actually air, pointeed out in the text below. Reinventing things on first principles [[2834|has been discussed before]] on [[xkcd]]. | |
| − | The title text references Albert Einstein's thought experiment where he imagined riding alongside a light particle/wave (which was referenced in | + | The title text references {{w|Albert Einstein|Albert Einstein's}} thought experiment where he imagined riding alongside a light particle/wave (which was referenced in [[2959: Beam of Light]]), but with a sound wave instead. Travelling at the speed of sound can be accomplished with a fast airplane. Usually these would be military aircraft, though the {{w|Tu-144}}, {{w|Concorde}}, and (briefly) [https://www.smithsonianmag.com/air-space-magazine/i-was-there-when-the-dc-8-went-supersonic-27846699/ a DC-8] were commercial aircraft that did achieve supersonic flight. |
==Transcript== | ==Transcript== | ||
| − | + | :[Ponytail is addressing an unseen audience in front of her while she holds her hand out towards them. She is standing on a podium with Cueball behind her. Cueball holds an arm out behind him indicating a screen behind him showing a graph with three sinus waves with different wavelengths. The top has two cycles, the middle four cycles and the bottom one cycle.] | |
| + | :Ponytail: We all know the speed of light is constant for all observers. | ||
| + | :Ponytail: But our experiments show that the speed of sound '''''changes''''' based on the observer's motion. | ||
| + | :Ponytail: Thus, we posit the existence of the '''''Soniferous Aether''''', a medium that fills the space between us and carries sound waves. | ||
| − | + | :[Caption below the panel:] | |
| + | :Sometimes physicists forget that air exists and rediscover it from first principles. | ||
| − | + | {{comic discussion}}<noinclude> | |
| − | + | [[Category:Comics featuring Cueball]] | |
| + | [[Category:Comics featuring Ponytail]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Physics]] | ||
Revision as of 08:39, 28 April 2026
| Soniferous Aether |
 Title text: Imagine you could ride alongside a sound wave. It would probably be pretty cool, right? We're putting in a departmental budget request to buy a really fast plane so we can check it out. |
Explanation
|
This is one of 69 incomplete explanations: This page was created recently by a BOT THAT BREATHES SONIFEROUS AETHER. Don't remove this notice too soon. If you can fix this issue, edit the page! |
This comic makes a joke on the speed of light and the speed of sound, and the way in which speed and light travel.
Beginning in the late 1690s, scientists posited a luminiferous aether to explain properties of light (especially its ability to travel in a vacuum) which should not be possible for a wave. The 1887 Michelson–Morley experiment disproved its existence, and nowadays this property is explained by wave–particle duality, which says that light can act as both a particle and a wave.
In this comic, Cueball & Ponytail are also sudgesting a luminous aether for the speed of sound instead. However, this 'aether' is actually air, pointeed out in the text below. Reinventing things on first principles has been discussed before on xkcd.
The title text references Albert Einstein's thought experiment where he imagined riding alongside a light particle/wave (which was referenced in 2959: Beam of Light), but with a sound wave instead. Travelling at the speed of sound can be accomplished with a fast airplane. Usually these would be military aircraft, though the Tu-144, Concorde, and (briefly) a DC-8 were commercial aircraft that did achieve supersonic flight.
Transcript
- [Ponytail is addressing an unseen audience in front of her while she holds her hand out towards them. She is standing on a podium with Cueball behind her. Cueball holds an arm out behind him indicating a screen behind him showing a graph with three sinus waves with different wavelengths. The top has two cycles, the middle four cycles and the bottom one cycle.]
- Ponytail: We all know the speed of light is constant for all observers.
- Ponytail: But our experiments show that the speed of sound changes based on the observer's motion.
- Ponytail: Thus, we posit the existence of the Soniferous Aether, a medium that fills the space between us and carries sound waves.
- [Caption below the panel:]
- Sometimes physicists forget that air exists and rediscover it from first principles.
Add comment 
Create topic (use sparingly) 
Refresh Discussion
Dunno how, but I managed to get to an XKCD comic within the first like 5 minutes of it's upload. Went ahead and added a really bare bones explanation. People funnier and smarter than me can take it from there. RG (talk) 04:24, 28 April 2026 (UTC)
managed to get to the xkcd comic before this page was even made somehow so yeah. --Utdtutyabthsc (talk) 04:49, 28 April 2026 (UTC)
ah, i have a script which polls for the new comic pages on comic days and sends a webhook to alert me as well as sending a request to another program of mine to index the new page, so i fairly often find that the wiki page has been made by the bot but is completely empty when i get to it--or on rare occasions the webhook triggers before the xkcd.com/<number> url can embed, apparently; i guess the comic metadata JSON gets filled in before the image is, or something like that? (the webhook triggers sending a message to discord with the link, which embeds 99% of the time) - Vaedez (talk) 05:03, 28 April 2026 (UTC)
"...however the Tu-144 and Concordé..." - why the rogue accent? Was the author's reasoning that, as a French word, it is de rigueur (see what I did there) for it to include accents? As errors go, it's acute one... 50.45.232.78 05:21, 28 April 2026 (UTC)
- The rogue accent has been removed with the speed of sound. But what about that supersonic DC-8. --Coconut Galaxy (talk) 05:26, 28 April 2026 (UTC)
Add comment
