Difference between revisions of "1287: Puzzle"

Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb.
Jump to: navigation, search
(Added some explanation about "White to ..." phrasing, and alternative interpretation.)
(Explanation)
Line 25: Line 25:
  
 
White eventually takes Black's king (presumably) at e8 with the checkmating Rook, and black responds by writing 0-1, which looks similar to the 0-0 notation for 'castling', but is in fact the notation used to declare that black has won the game - perhaps the psychological game of forcing white to play 'Chess' after the checkmate, thereby forcing white to concede that the game is not - after all - chess. White protests this 'move' too, and black spills the board.
 
White eventually takes Black's king (presumably) at e8 with the checkmating Rook, and black responds by writing 0-1, which looks similar to the 0-0 notation for 'castling', but is in fact the notation used to declare that black has won the game - perhaps the psychological game of forcing white to play 'Chess' after the checkmate, thereby forcing white to concede that the game is not - after all - chess. White protests this 'move' too, and black spills the board.
 +
 +
A hybrid game of Go-Chess could perhaps be fought in a similar manner to Chess Boxing, but with perhaps more interaction between the Go and Chess games: Go stones surrounding a chess square could remove the chess piece; diagonally-moving chess pieces could 'take' Go stones from the corners in the move from one diagonal square to another, in a manner perhaps reminiscent of drafts/chequers.
  
 
{{w|Magnus Carlsen}} is a 22 year old Norwegian chess grandmaster, who had the highest peak rating and was the third youngest grandmaster in history. He was the world's 2009 blitz champion. {{w|Viswanathan Anand}} is a 43 year old Indian grandmaster has been undisputed World Champion since 2007. Carlsen and Anand are due to face each other {{w|World Chess Championship 2013|in November 2013}}
 
{{w|Magnus Carlsen}} is a 22 year old Norwegian chess grandmaster, who had the highest peak rating and was the third youngest grandmaster in history. He was the world's 2009 blitz champion. {{w|Viswanathan Anand}} is a 43 year old Indian grandmaster has been undisputed World Champion since 2007. Carlsen and Anand are due to face each other {{w|World Chess Championship 2013|in November 2013}}

Revision as of 12:47, 6 November 2013

Puzzle
Prediction for Carlsen v. Anand: ... 25. Qb8+ Nxb8 26. Rd8# f6 27. "... dude." Qf5 28. "The game is over, dude." Qxg5 29. Rxe8 0-1 30. "Dude, your move can't be '0-1'. Don't write that down." [Black flips board]
Title text: Prediction for Carlsen v. Anand: ... 25. Qb8+ Nxb8 26. Rd8# f6 27. "... dude." Qf5 28. "The game is over, dude." Qxg5 29. Rxe8 0-1 30. "Dude, your move can't be '0-1'. Don't write that down." [Black flips board]

Explanation

Ambox notice.png This explanation may be incomplete or incorrect:
Please include the reason why this explanation is incomplete, like this: {{incomplete|reason}}

If you can address this issue, please edit the page! Thanks.

The game of go (also called Weiqi, Baduk or Igo) is usually played on the 19×19 intersections of a grid, but sometimes a faster, simpler version is played on the 9×9 intersections of a grid (which thus has 8×8 squares, as a chessboard, though they are not colored in an alternating pattern - introduced to chess in the 13th century). In the comic, white has chess figures and plays against black, which uses go stones.

In chess, the phrasing "White to move" indicates that it's the White player's turn; "White to play and win" indicates that it's White's turn and the next move (if White plays correctly) will win the game. The caption "White to continue insisting this is a chessboard" is a play on this traditional phrasing.

Two versions of the board were posted by Randall: both had white after P-e3, P-d4, N-f3, N-c3, but the first with an extra bishop at e4 (B@e4), the second after B-d2.

B@e4 in the first version of the board was perhaps intended to represent confusion in White's mind whether he was playing Go (placing a piece) or Chess (it's a chess piece) - as a 'placement' this move could have been first, and could explain P-e3 with e4 already being blocked.

It it unclear whether black has gone first (as is traditional in Go) with five Go stones (none in the 3-3 handicap positions marked on a 9x9 Go board) vs five chess moves. White moves first has been traditional in Chess for about a century.

The title text is in the format of a game transcript, starting on the 25th move. Black is making chess moves, apparently having accepted that it is a game of chess after all.

At 25, white's Queen moves to b8 for check and is captured by black's Knight taking it, but after white's Rook checkmates at d8 (denoted by #; presumably the king is trapped on 8 behind pawns), Black (illegally) continues to play with something moving to f6 (this could be interpreted as a Go move), and responds to White's protests with the chess moves Queen to f5 and then Queen takes at g5.

White eventually takes Black's king (presumably) at e8 with the checkmating Rook, and black responds by writing 0-1, which looks similar to the 0-0 notation for 'castling', but is in fact the notation used to declare that black has won the game - perhaps the psychological game of forcing white to play 'Chess' after the checkmate, thereby forcing white to concede that the game is not - after all - chess. White protests this 'move' too, and black spills the board.

A hybrid game of Go-Chess could perhaps be fought in a similar manner to Chess Boxing, but with perhaps more interaction between the Go and Chess games: Go stones surrounding a chess square could remove the chess piece; diagonally-moving chess pieces could 'take' Go stones from the corners in the move from one diagonal square to another, in a manner perhaps reminiscent of drafts/chequers.

Magnus Carlsen is a 22 year old Norwegian chess grandmaster, who had the highest peak rating and was the third youngest grandmaster in history. He was the world's 2009 blitz champion. Viswanathan Anand is a 43 year old Indian grandmaster has been undisputed World Champion since 2007. Carlsen and Anand are due to face each other in November 2013

For white, this match is initially similar to the 16th Amber Tournament (Blindfold) match between Carlsen and Anand. Since the match was blindfold, perhaps this contributed to the confusion over whether the game was Chess or Go </humour>.

An alternative interpretation is that the game shown in the picture, and the one predicted in the title text, are two separate games: the title text does not describe the game in the picture. The pictured game flaunts the rules of chess by mixing it with go; the title game takes the humor up a notch by imagining chess grandmasters engaging in petty bickering after a win when one of them keeps playing.

Transcript

[A game board with 8x8 white squares and black borders, like a goboard or an all white chessboard, there are white chess pieces in starting position on the bottom after P-e3, P-d4, N-f3, N-c3, B-d2 and five black Go pieces on the edges in the center of the board on d4 d5 c6 g4 g6.]
White to continue insisting this is a chessboard


comment.png add a comment! ⋅ comment.png add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ Icons-mini-action refresh blue.gif refresh comments!

Discussion

So is there an answer to the puzzle? Clwhisk (talk) 19:06, 6 November 2013 (UTC)

Re5. This forks the two topmost black stones, allows the queen to attack one black and to develop, and in addition keeps the two eyes on d3 and e2, ensuring that white continues to live. Dominique. 172.69.150.106 15:33, 9 January 2024 (UTC)

Black thinks he's playing Go and white thinks he's playing chess. Although a 7 x 7 board is a bit small for go, it is not unusual for a beginner to play on such a board -- hax (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

It is a 9x9 go board! (usually used for learning,  as its smaller, less strategic, and quicker to finish game, whereas regular go is played on 19x19 intersections). Olivier.  108.162.229.17 (talk)  (please sign your comments with ~~~~)
You beat me to it. "Less strategic" also means "more tactical". In my experience, 9x9 boards are rare (mostly, people would just use part of a 19x19 board), but when they do exist, they have 4 handicap intersections marked with dots. Homunq (talk) 08:28, 6 November 2013 (UTC)
9x9 boards are great for variety and getting through games, and for beginners of all levels! Go on a 9x9 is about as hard as chess, in terms of playability, state space, and only recently seeing pro strength computers. Clwhisk (talk) 18:59, 6 November 2013 (UTC)

The picture on xkcd.com is changed. The bishop on e4 is removed and the one on c1 moved to d2. 141.101.93.11 08:48, 6 November 2013 (UTC) Could this be another Time Lapse much like the Wait For It comic?--108.162.221.31 02:31, 8 November 2013 (UTC)

It only changed once, to fix a legal error with a move. Davidy²²[talk] 02:41, 8 November 2013 (UTC)

Would it be better to use algebraic notation instead, seeing as FIDE stopped recognizing descriptive notation in 1981? -- Banak (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

Possibly - I was trying to distinguish between Go moves and Chess moves by using the older Chess notation as a disambiguation, but... eh. I'm ambinotational - I read metric and imperial and barely notice the conversion. :) SleekWeasel (talk) 11:18, 6 November 2013 (UTC)
Then you may have a career at NASA ahead of you... ;) 141.101.98.214 14:26, 6 November 2013 (UTC)
Haha, NASA approached me once about designing a catsuit/pressuresuit, based on my stretchy.org website, thinking that I lived in Cambridge Mass, not Cambridge UK. SleekWeasel (talk) 23:35, 6 November 2013 (UTC)

It would be helpful to give a description - or at least a primer (or a link to one) - of the notation used for chess moves (i.e. Q, N, R ... x, +, #, ... which sides of the board are alphabetic vs. which are numeric). 108.162.221.228 16:55, 6 November 2013 (UTC)


Re: black not playing on a handicap positions: it may be that black considers the players evenly matched (or white to be only slightly better), so no handicap. If there was a handicap, black would have 6 stones on the board (I've never heard of a 1 stone handicap). In any case, the upper-right move is a traditional starting move (assuming black is facing the board from the top), as it gives good control over the corner (and in a 9x9, the center).108.162.219.52 14:28, 7 November 2013 (UTC) -TauCeti

Also, as a note, it looks like the two players are playing in response to each other. Black is playing in contact with the white pieces as a tactical play to contest that section of the board, while white is carefully positioning their pieces to protect against a player who has somehow taken control over the center of the board (although white is treating the go stones as more valuable than pawns, or the knights wouldn't be there).108.162.219.52 14:28, 7 November 2013 (UTC) -TauCeti

How did that bishop get out? 141.101.98.195 17:04, 7 November 2013 (UTC)
Do you mean the light-squared bishop or the, uh, other light-squared bishop? --108.162.218.59 15:42, 8 November 2013 (UTC)
I mean the light one that's not in its starting location, but out mingling with the pawns 141.101.98.195 16:57, 11 November 2013 (UTC)

I have to say, Black's position is extremely unusual for Go. The two uppermost stones are on 4-4 and 3-4 (counted from the edge of the board as 1). A 4-4 opening invites a corner invasion, which could be a disaster in a 9x9 game, especially if your opponent has another corner. A one stone handicap is pretty common, as this would just mean playing without komi (the few points white gets to counter black's advantage for going first). Playing on the handicap points (3-3 in 9x9, and 4-4 in 19x19) are usually considered just decent starting points, apart form their use in handicapped games. Of course, there are many different openings, especially in even games, so there's plenty of different moves to play. But 4-4 in 9x9 still seems exceedingly unusual. 199.27.128.182 16:28, 8 November 2013 (UTC)greyaenigma

I figured that the 3-4 move was black's first, and the remaining moves were in response to white (where the 4-4 was to shore up the left side of the board). That said, I generally play on 19x19 and play rather poorly, so I'd trust your judgement over mine. 108.162.219.15 18:48, 8 November 2013 (UTC) -TauCeti

It's interesting to note that in Japan, Go vs Shogi (a Japanese variant of chess) is not uncommon, however the game is played on a Shogi board, and the go stones are placed in the squares, rather than on the intersections. 199.27.130.174 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

That feel when you can tell the author uses the same online chess website that you do because of how the chess pieces are drawn. 173.245.56.175 (talk) (please sign your comments with ~~~~)

As I could not give good current statistics and couldn't find those of november 2013, I removed the statistics. If anyone can do so, please readd them, and mention the validity date of them.--Lupo (talk) 12:23, 8 March 2019 (UTC)